The NFL players on who the best WR in the NFC East is.....

[Midswat]

Thats somewhat right but the players are the ones playing each other... You would think they would know best.

If you asked 100 DT's to rank all the DT's in the NFL, and then posted that list, maybe you'd have a point.

But what does Tommy Harris know about evaluating tight ends? What does Flozell Adams know about breaking down receivers?

Nothing. Less than nothing.

 

[NoShame]

If you asked 100 DT's to rank all the DT's in the NFL, and then posted that list, maybe you'd have a point.

But what does Tommy Harris know about evaluating tight ends? What does Flozell Adams know about breaking down receivers?

Nothing. Less than nothing.

Then its equal to that of any of us.

 

[LAZARUS_LOGAN]

He's light years better than Jackson too

I don't know about light years, but he defintely IS better from a purist standpoint as to what a WR is able to do.

 

[LAZARUS_LOGAN]

Devin Hester is ranked #32.

He, like Jackson, received such a high ranking because of his return ability was taken into consideration.

Greg Jennings is ranked #74, and he's lightyears better than Hester.

I'm not even sure if Hester should be ranked so high on his return ability anymore. I think maybe Cribbs might have passed him up in that area.

 

[LAZARUS_LOGAN]

Let's not act like players sit through the regular season watching tape of every NFL player. They're just watching the highlights like we all are and highlight plays sell.

They do however watch more tape on most players than us, because their job requires it.

 

[sbk92]

Thats somewhat right but the players are the ones playing each other... You would think they would know best.

They have a much more informed opinion than the fans. For every smart fan, you have 4 or 5 of these people who want to somehow dismiss the fact that everyone in and out of the league thinks Jackson is the best.

If he's a Cowboy, this is, like, a totally awesome kick ass balls on polling.

Doesn't matter. It's crystal clear now that this is a fantasy land. In reality, there is no question who the best WR in the division is.

 

[sbk92]

**** this thread is stupid.

Can football please get back so we can see first how just how "great" Jackson is and wish that SBK would go back onto his little island.?

If you haven't already seen how great he is, I'm guessing you're too f'n stupid to ever see it.

Ya know who has seen it? The players, the writers, the fans.

 

[Cythim]

This poll is as unbiased a poll as you can possibly put together. It works for or against nobody. For every player with some fantasy anti-Cowboys, lets keep all that scary talent down, bias there's another with pro-Cowboys bias. Bias had jack and squat to do with the results of the poll.

The homers just don't like the results. So let's attack the integrity of the poll.

I won't play along in some fantasy land where the poll would disagree with me. The poll would never disagree with me. Because I'm right.

That is like saying "this midget is as tall a midget as you could possibly get." He is still a short little fuck and the poll is still biased.

 

[sbk92]

That is like saying "this midget is as tall a midget as you could possibly get." He is still a short little fuck and the poll is still biased.

That about sums up the intelligence level of those handful of people who want to pretend this polling means nothing.

 

[Cythim]

That about sums up the intelligence level of those handful of people who want to pretend this polling means nothing.

Indeed!

 

[sbk92]

Check this out - Polling NFL players on who the best NFL players are is just a waste of time.

What we need to do is poll the fans.

Wait. Not all the fans. They agreed with the players. Just Cowboys fans. Who read here. They got it figured out. You'd get the real truff there.

 

[Cythim]

Check this out - Polling NFL players on who the best NFL players are is just a waste of time.

What we need to do is poll the fans.

Wait. Not all the fans. They agreed with the players. Just Cowboys fans. Who read here. They got it figured out. You'd get the real truff there.

Because that is what everyone is clamoring for, amirite?

Check out these quotes, they are from before SBK realized his favorite player was ranked ahead of Austin.

If Ware isn't top 10, blow this list up and start over.

How the hell can you have Devin Hester ranked ahead of Jason Witten?

How can you even have him on the list at all? He's a better player than Tony Romo? Wellwaitwhat?

 

[sbk92]

Because that is what everyone is clamoring for, amirite?

Check out these quotes, they are from before SBK realized his favorite player was ranked ahead of Austin.

I said I didn't agree with every ranking.

But when the players, writers and fans all say the same thing.....you might want to start thinking it's probably correct.

 

[sbk92]

I haven't read a single person who isn't a mindless Cowboys homer say that Jackson isn't the best in the division.

 

[Cythim]

I'm not debating Jackson, I am telling you that the player's opinion is not a valid argument to prove your position.

 

[sbk92]

I'm not debating Jackson, I am telling you that the player's opinion is not a valid argument to prove your position.

Sure it is.

It's about the best you can get. They've done three polls. All three agree with me. None agree with the homers here. Once you get the bias out of there, it's a clean sweep for Jackson.

The reason being he's just clearly the best. If it was even close you'd see them much closer together. But it's Jackson ........ and then everybody else.

The entire NFL world laughs at you, soccer fag.

 

[RoyTheHammer]

Because it's not even a debatable issue. Jackson has been that much better than any other the last two years.

Past 2 years:

Miles Austin - 150 catches, 2360 yards 18 TD's

D. Jackson - 109 catches, 2210 yards 15 TD's

Yup.

 

[Midswat]

Wait.... so we're biased homers because we disagree that Jackson is the best receiver in the East?

Even though most of us are saying that honor goes to Hakeem Nicks?

Are we Giants homers now?

lol

sbk92 playbook, page one - Can't win argument? Call people homers!

 

[Cythim]

Sure it is.

It's about the best you can get. They've done three polls. All three agree with me. None agree with the homers here. Once you get the bias out of there, it's a clean sweep for Jackson.

The reason being he's just clearly the best. If it was even close you'd see them much closer together. But it's Jackson ........ and then everybody else.

The entire NFL world laughs at you, soccer fag.

oh noes he called me a soccer fag, talk about total pwnage!

Grow up and accept your defeat. This poll is nothing more than a talking point. Trying to use it as proof is like pointing at Obama's approval rating to rank him against other presidents.

 

[Cythim]

Wait.... so we're biased homers because we disagree that Jackson is the best receiver in the East?

Even though most of us are saying that honor goes to Hakeem Nicks?

Are we Giants homers now?

lol

sbk92 playbook, page one - Can't win argument? Call people homers!

Nicks didn't even break into the poll, so he must suck amirite!?!