Ranking Jerry Jones as a GM

[Jon88]

Switzer won a SB with Jimmy's team. What's your point?

13-3 had nothing to do with Bill leaving Wade a stacked roster that was maturing. Nothing?

I guess you guys don't see the pattern. Good coach leaves, team does well for a year or two, then turns into piece of shit.

It's happened twice.

It obviously took the team going to shit twice for him to learn. He should have learned the first time. The years from '94 to '04 should have fixed his thinking, but it didn't.

 

[Sheik]

It obviously took the team going to shit twice for him to learn. He should have learned the first time. The years from '94 to '04 should have fixed his thinking, but it didn't.

I actually thought he had learned after hiring Bill. I think that whole experience made him slightly better than he had been. You don't sit in a room with someone like BP for 4 years and not pick up on some things.

I think hiring Wade was a bitch move. He was never going to suddenly become a good head coach. Same with the other guy Jerry had interest in. He was looking for someone he could impose his will on if he thought he needed to do so.

He's not the worst, but he's nowhere near the top of that GM list. Just to clarify, he's done some things right.

 

[Jon88]

I actually thought he had learned after hiring Bill. I think that whole experience made him slightly better than he had been. You don't sit in a room with someone like BP for 4 years and not pick up on some things.

I think hiring Wade was a bitch move. He was never going to suddenly become a good head coach. Same with the other guy Jerry had interest in. He was looking for someone he could impose his will on if he thought he needed to do so.

He's not the worst, but he's nowhere near the top of that GM list. Just to clarify, he's done some things right.

He went back to his old ways after Bill left and that's what's so frustrating. If it didn't work the first time with a much more talented team then why would it this time? I don't understand what was going through his head.

 

[Midswat]

No one has bothered to actually rank them?

Everything that you guys have said thus far, has already been said.

 

[Sheik]

No one has bothered to actually rank them?

Everything that you guys have said thus far, has already been said.

I will when I have some vacation time.

 

[cmd34]

No one has bothered to actually rank them?

Everything that you guys have said thus far, has already been said.

Doesn't make it not true.

 

[Cr122]

Here's my ranking of the GM's.


1. Floyd Reese/Bill Belichick- New England
2. Ted Thompson- Green Bay Packers
3. Ozzie Newsome- Baltimore Ravens
4. Bill/Chris Polian- Indianapolis Colts
5. Mickey Loomis- New Orleans Saints
6. Kevin Colbert- Pittsburgh Steelers
7. Scott Pioli- Kansas City Chiefs
8. Mike Tannenbaum- New York Jets
9. Jerry Reese- New York Giants
10. Mark Dominik- Tampa Bay Buccaneers
11. Martin Mayhew- Detroit Lions
12. A.J. Smith- San Diego Chargers
13. Tom Heckert- Cleveland Browns
14. Rick Spielman- Minnesota Vikings
15. Thomas Dimitroff- Atlanta Falcons
16. Mike Reinfeldt- Tennessee Titans
17. Howie Roseman/ Andy Reid- Philadelphia Eagles
18. Billy Devaney- St. Louis Rams
19. Rick Smith- Houston Texans
20. Jerry Angelo- Chicago Bears
21. Jerry Jones- Dallas Cowboys
22. John Schneider- Seattle Seahawks
23. Rod Graves- Arizona Cardinals
24. Jeff Ireland- Miami Dolphins
25. Bruce Allen- Washington Redskins
26. Marty Hurney- Carolina Panthers
27. Trent Baalke- San Francisco 49ers
28.Brian Xanders- Denver Broncos
29. Buddy Nix- Buffalo Bills
30.Gene Smith- Jacksonville Jaguars
31. Mike Brown- Cincinnati Bengals
32. Al Davis- Oakland Raiders

 

[Jon88]

That puts him in the 35th percentile. 65% of the other GMs out there are better.

 

[2233boys]

Here's my ranking of the GM's.


1. Floyd Reese/Bill Belichick- New England
2. Ted Thompson- Green Bay Packers
3. Ozzie Newsome- Baltimore Ravens
4. Bill/Chris Polian- Indianapolis Colts
5. Mickey Loomis- New Orleans Saints
6. Kevin Colbert- Pittsburgh Steelers
7. Scott Pioli- Kansas City Chiefs
8. Mike Tannenbaum- New York Jets
9. Jerry Reese- New York Giants
10. Mark Dominik- Tampa Bay Buccaneers
11. Martin Mayhew- Detroit Lions
12. A.J. Smith- San Diego Chargers
13. Tom Heckert- Cleveland Browns
14. Rick Spielman- Minnesota Vikings
15. Thomas Dimitroff- Atlanta Falcons
16. Mike Reinfeldt- Tennessee Titans
17. Howie Roseman/ Andy Reid- Philadelphia Eagles
18. Billy Devaney- St. Louis Rams
19. Rick Smith- Houston Texans
20. Jerry Angelo- Chicago Bears
21. Jerry Jones- Dallas Cowboys
22. John Schneider- Seattle Seahawks
23. Rod Graves- Arizona Cardinals
24. Jeff Ireland- Miami Dolphins
25. Bruce Allen- Washington Redskins
26. Marty Hurney- Carolina Panthers
27. Trent Baalke- San Francisco 49ers
28.Brian Xanders- Denver Broncos
29. Buddy Nix- Buffalo Bills
30.Gene Smith- Jacksonville Jaguars
31. Mike Brown- Cincinnati Bengals
32. Al Davis- Oakland Raiders

I would have the Eagles in the top 10 ceretainly higher then the Bucs and Lions. I also think the Bears should be a little higher and Browns lower. But aside from that, I am ok with where Jerry is at on at that list 20-25 is about right.

 

[Cr122]

I would have the Eagles in the top 10 ceretainly higher then the Bucs and Lions. I also think the Bears should be a little higher and Browns lower. But aside from that, I am ok with where Jerry is at on at that list 20-25 is about right.

Yeah, I guess Philly could've been ranked better. Oh, well.

 

[Clutch88]

I have Jerry as the worst Dallas Cowboy GM in the history of the franchise. And that's all that matters, i won't bore you with the obvious reasons.

 

[Midswat]

Yeah, I guess Philly could've been ranked better. Oh, well.

I think the Eagles are about where they should be. They churn out some crap drafts every third year or so.

 

[Cr122]

I think the Eagles are about where they should be. They churn out some crap drafts every third year or so.

This.

Thanks, buddy.

 

[Cr122]

The one GM that I'm really interested in this year is Mike Brown.

I want to see what he does with all that cap room.

I bet nothing.

 

[superpunk]

Here's my ranking of the GM's.


1. Floyd Reese/Bill Belichick- New England
2. Ted Thompson- Green Bay Packers
3. Ozzie Newsome- Baltimore Ravens
4. Bill/Chris Polian- Indianapolis Colts
5. Mickey Loomis- New Orleans Saints
6. Kevin Colbert- Pittsburgh Steelers
7. Scott Pioli- Kansas City Chiefs
8. Mike Tannenbaum- New York Jets
9. Jerry Reese- New York Giants
10. Mark Dominik- Tampa Bay Buccaneers
11. Martin Mayhew- Detroit Lions
12. A.J. Smith- San Diego Chargers
13. Tom Heckert- Cleveland Browns
14. Rick Spielman- Minnesota Vikings
15. Thomas Dimitroff- Atlanta Falcons
16. Mike Reinfeldt- Tennessee Titans
17. Howie Roseman/ Andy Reid- Philadelphia Eagles
18. Billy Devaney- St. Louis Rams
19. Rick Smith- Houston Texans
20. Jerry Angelo- Chicago Bears
21. Jerry Jones- Dallas Cowboys
22. John Schneider- Seattle Seahawks
23. Rod Graves- Arizona Cardinals
24. Jeff Ireland- Miami Dolphins
25. Bruce Allen- Washington Redskins
26. Marty Hurney- Carolina Panthers
27. Trent Baalke- San Francisco 49ers
28.Brian Xanders- Denver Broncos
29. Buddy Nix- Buffalo Bills
30.Gene Smith- Jacksonville Jaguars
31. Mike Brown- Cincinnati Bengals
32. Al Davis- Oakland Raiders

I completely agree, just because I can't believe you took the time to do this.

 

[dbair1967]

Real ranking:

1) Jerruh

2-32) everyone else

 

[Cr122]

Real ranking:

1) Jerruh

2-32) everyone else

 

[marionbarberthe4th]

Did it have to be that big champ? I bet google had a few other pics

 

[Cr122]

Did it have to be that big champ? I bet google had a few other pics

Sorry, is this better?

 

[marionbarberthe4th]

How come they can show cartoon asses but not dongs?