dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
58,648
Reaction score
9,114
Flag or two hand touch on the QB isn't far away. This is fucking pathetic. I hate everything about how Goodell runs this league.



NFL will look at making QBs safer


Updated: November 14, 2013, 8:25 PM ET
Associated Press


Thanks to a broken collarbone on a run-of-the-mill sack, the Green Bay Packers are without Aaron Rodgers. Their rivals in the NFC North, the Chicago Bears, are without Jay Cutler thanks to a bum leg, which also wasn't the result of some sort of illegal hit.

Game after game, NFL quarterbacks get sacked, get hurt -- and miss starts. Of the 15 games on this week's schedule, nine -- 60 percent -- feature at least one team that has been forced to change its quarterback because of injury this season.

One of the two teams with a bye, St. Louis, lost its No. 1 guy, 2010 top overall draft pick Sam Bradford, for the season. Bradford, who tore a ligament in his left knee last month, is one of nine quarterbacks on injured reserve in 2013, the second most through 10 weeks in any of the past 15 seasons, according to STATS.

Amid those regular reminders of the dangers facing players at the sport's marquee position, the league's competition committee will take a look this offseason at whether to expand rules that protect the QB, NFL vice president of officiating Dean Blandino said Thursday.

"Should he always get protection from low hits or head hits, regardless of the posture he's presenting?" Blandino said in a telephone interview. "Part of the conversation will be: Should that protection be expanded to all times when the quarterback has the ball in the pocket?"

The committee will review position-by-position injury data and go over video from games, a regular process between seasons.

"Currently the quarterback is as protected now as he's ever been," Blandino said, "but I think that's been the case for eight or nine years."

A year ago, only one QB had gone on IR by this point in the season. Indeed, 2012 was about as healthy as it gets for quarterbacks: 20 of 32 NFL teams started the same one in every game, the highest percentage for a full, non-strike season since the AFL-NFL merger in 1970. With nearly half of this season still to play, the number of teams able to rely on one starter at that key spot already is down to 20.

"If you don't have someone who can be productive at that position, you're not going to win many games. You need to keep your quarterback healthy, because on most teams, there's a huge drop-off from the starter to the backup. It's a watered-down position, because there's not a lot of great guys after the top 15 or so," Hall of Fame quarterback Warren Moon said. "When you get a good guy, you want to keep him healthy."

Moon sees quite a difference in the way the position is safeguarded nowadays, compared with when he was in the NFL from 1984-2000.

"No question, I wish we were protected better. ... It's a lot safer, because some of the hits we took back in the day -- they could still drive us into the turf when they hit us. Those really were painful. Didn't always cause an injury, but made you a little more antsy about taking hits. The guys these days don't really have to put up with it," Moon said. "I don't think there's much more you can do. It's as good as it's going to get, unless you put flags on them."

He pointed to today's spread offenses, with empty backfields and fewer players hanging back to help in pass protection, as a major reason games are averaging 2.65 sacks, a half-sack more per game than in 2010, for example. That's on pace for the highest rate since the 2.67 in 1986.

It probably is not a coincidence that the seven teams with sole possession of first place in their division entering Thursday started the same guy behind center every week: New England (Tom Brady), Indianapolis (Andrew Luck), Cincinnati (Andy Dalton), Kansas City (Alex Smith), New Orleans (Drew Brees), Detroit (Matthew Stafford) and Seattle (Russell Wilson). So has Denver (Peyton Manning), which at 8-1 has the league's second-best record but is in second place in the AFC West behind unbeaten Kansas City entering their showdown Sunday night.

Already using three QBs are Buffalo, Cleveland and Green Bay, which put Rodgers' backup, Seneca Wallace, on IR, after he oh-so-briefly took over the job. The Packers now have Scott Tolzien, until recently a practice squad member, calling signals against the Giants on Sunday.

The Broncos got a scare last weekend, when Manning limped around after a low hit late in a victory against San Diego. After he skipped practice Wednesday while getting treatment on his sore right ankle, Manning was asked about the slew of QB health issues around the league.

"I don't like talking about it. I don't know what the trends are at other places, but I never like to see a quarterback get injured, I will say that," said the four-time NFL MVP, who was at practice Thursday. "Quarterbacks are a unique fraternity. We kind of pull for one another. Maybe not when you're playing against them that day. Cutler's been injured. I know Rodgers was out. As a quarterback, you don't like to see those guys get injured. I hope they'll be back out there as soon as they can."

So, of course, do their teams.
 

VTA

UDFA
Messages
2,668
Reaction score
594
Check out the flag against the e9'ers Brooks, for his absolutely clean hit on Brees.
Link

Pretty lousy that this crap is deciding the outcome of the game instead of a teams ability to step it up and win on it's own merits.

"I didn't hit him with my hand or my helmet," Brooks said, via the San Francisco Chronicle. "I basically bear-hugged him. That's just how football is played. I think this s--- is bull----. Football, the way they call stuff these days, it's watered down. It ain't real no more."

Because football is no longer a sport, it's simply entertainment. Soon the fixes will be blatantly in.

We've seen the Packers struggle to make plays without signal-caller Aaron Rodgers. If calls like this one save us from watching Luke McCown try to move the Saints' offense, we'll have to accept the occasional complaints about a sport gone soft.
 
Last edited:
Messages
8,660
Reaction score
0
He clotheslined Brees and came in contact with his neck. You can complain that shouldn't be illegal, but the way the rules are, it's absolutely a penalty.
 

Jon88

Pro Bowler
Messages
19,523
Reaction score
0
Oh no he touched his neck!

Fuck the NFL. I'm about to stop watching it and just watch kids playing flag football on Saturdays.

Think I'm joking? Wanna bet $100? Didn't think so.
 

VTA

UDFA
Messages
2,668
Reaction score
594
He clotheslined Brees and came in contact with his neck. You can complain that shouldn't be illegal, but the way the rules are, it's absolutely a penalty.

I don't think he clothes-lined him, really. His arm hit his neck accidentally and the natural consequence of him in motion had its effect. My complaint is the rule and the silliness of making sure natural consequence not be part of competition in order to make it 'fun' to watch. We can watch movies to engage our minds in predictable entertainment. I'm not too bummed over this issue; I know where it's going and I'm sure the allure of football will just eventually fade as it no longer matters how you play the game or even if you win or lose, but how high the ratings and advertising dollars.
 

ThoughtExperiment

Quality Starter
Messages
9,906
Reaction score
3
It was a terrible call.

VTA mentions the fixes coming soon... I wouldn't call it a "fix" exactly, but that's an example of the NBA-ization of the league, with the stars getting different treatment than other players. And it absolutely sucks.
 

Jon88

Pro Bowler
Messages
19,523
Reaction score
0
Yeah. Remember when scrambling QBs seemed to be the future? It's why we took Quintelle in the 2nd round.
 

Bob Sacamano

All-Pro
Messages
26,436
Reaction score
3
Where's dbair to bitch about our injury woes? oh wait...

But can you guys only imagine if Romo were to go down? And he's been pretty subpar the past few weeks.

That would be a nightmare.
 

bbgun

Administrator
Messages
15,176
Reaction score
2,367
Brees' shortness made the penalty happen. Had he been 6'2" or taller, the tackler gets him mid-chest.
 

ThoughtExperiment

Quality Starter
Messages
9,906
Reaction score
3
Yep. Or even a lot heavier and stronger. If that's Ben Roethlisberger, the exact same hit doesn't look as bad and it's probably no call.

Goodell is like the Jerry of commissioners.
 

Jon88

Pro Bowler
Messages
19,523
Reaction score
0
Where's dbair to bitch about our injury woes? oh wait...

But can you guys only imagine if Romo were to go down? And he's been pretty subpar the past few weeks.

That would be a nightmare.

It wouldn't matter at all. No running game, Dez is targeted at most 4 times a game. This offense sucks ass.
 

bbgun

Administrator
Messages
15,176
Reaction score
2,367
You can't hit a QB high and you can't hit him low. Soon they'll be wearing those red jerseys you see in training camp.
 
Messages
8,660
Reaction score
0
I hate the rule and I hate what Goodell is doing to football.

That said, if I was a ref in that game, I would have thrown the flag. Everyone in here has probably seen the replay in slow motion 200 times from 4 different angles. The ref doesn't have that luxury.

And the rule says you can't come in contact with the QBs head or neck. By the letter of the law, it's a penalty. Our players have been flagged for hits where they sort of incidentally hit the QBs head or neck, and probably less violent hits than this one.

It's just the state of the league now. QBs (not named Romo) are over-protected.
 
Top Bottom