Messages
2,329
Reaction score
11
[video=youtube;GPoYnT5umFw]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GPoYnT5umFw[/video]

awwww yeahhh

Touchdown was great. Romo's throw was a threaded needle on a rocket.

That was not an OL issue at all. All of the WRs had time to get into their routes but they were all covered. How is that possible with Dez, Miles, Murray and Witten ll overmatching their defenders? And how long does Romo have to stand back there until someone shakes free? Thatis not a scheme. That is chaos, that Jason relies on the players, not his own design, to rectify.

This is my issue. The scheme creates two major problems.

In a micro-organized scheme like a WCO, there are isolated hot reads that immediately are either open or have a lot of attention (which allow others to be open immediately). If you look at the play, there are a few players that are immediately in position (Dez and Murray) but the scheme calls for the routes to be completed to the defensive open voids, so Romo has to wait and choose, rather than get the ball into the hands of the skill position player for YAC. Getting the ball into the hands of the runner has more ball security and probability for at least minor sucess, but perhaps less big play payoff. Waiting, like Romo has to, puts him at risk, puts the ball security at risk but the payoff (typically improbable), is the big downfield play. Last year, throwing the ball 648 times for 65% completion rate means that Romo somehow had the time to make those completions and attempts in this ridiculous scheme. How would that happen with a weak OL who can't hold their blocks? They have to hold their blocks longer in this scheme than. Any other scheme in the league. So if Romo has to wait and then finally choose who is the MOST open, the play extends longer than it should and he keeps the ball longer than he needs to. Parcells cautioned Romo about trying to make a play rather than just getting rid of the ball.

The second problem is: if you look at the secondary, the Redskins have a very good idea of where Dallas is running the routes. This is from a few years ago but nothing has changed. It is a scheme without design or direction, just a bunch of recognizable tendencies that are still not fooling anyone. I realize that a TD is a TD and points are points, but Garrett was smiling as if his play was successful. Romo's play was successful. Garrett's play did nothing. I remember Lawrence Taylor getting yelled at by Parcells for free-lancing on a play even though it resulted in a huge sack. The point was Parcells, it may work once, but probably not twice.

Just hope Romo and Callahan overrule the Red Idiocy this season.
 
Messages
2,450
Reaction score
0
Witten isn't a hall of famer

He's never been the best TE, just crazy consistent and durable.
2012 lead the league in catches and yrds for TE
2011 third in yrds 6th in rec
2010 lead the league in catches and yrds for TE
2009 third in yrds 2nd in the league rec
2008 2nd in yrds 3rd in rec
2007 2nd in yrds and rec
2006 7th in both
2005 7th in yrds 6th in rec
2004 2nd in both
2003 20th in yrds 18th in rec

So in 10 years he has lead the league twice in yrds and rec, been in the top 3 in both 4 times. Plus is going to be second all time this year in rec and could be number 2 in yrds with 1200 yrds. Yeah he has never been the best in the league.
 
Messages
10,636
Reaction score
0
2012 lead the league in catches and yrds for TE
2011 third in yrds 6th in rec
2010 lead the league in catches and yrds for TE
2009 third in yrds 2nd in the league rec
2008 2nd in yrds 3rd in rec
2007 2nd in yrds and rec
2006 7th in both
2005 7th in yrds 6th in rec
2004 2nd in both
2003 20th in yrds 18th in rec

So in 10 years he has lead the league twice in yrds and rec, been in the top 3 in both 4 times. Plus is going to be second all time this year in rec and could be number 2 in yrds with 1200 yrds. Yeah he has never been the best in the league.

Wow thank you for proving my point.
 

ThoughtExperiment

Quality Starter
Messages
9,906
Reaction score
3
I know you hate Garrett, and pass plays in the redzone where Witten stays into block are as dumb as the defensive coaches who use DeMarcus ware in pass coverage on 3rd down and obvious pass situations. That said, Witten runs plenty of patterns in the redzone and endzone. Garrett doesn't decide who to throw the football too. he doesn't have a playstation controller in his hand that forces Romo to throw the ball to certain players. The QB ultimately decides who to throw the football to. I don't know why this is such a hard concept for some of you to grasp.
People like Sturm have written about how Witten stays in to block way too often on plays close to the endzone. What, you think Witten is open in the endzone and Romo just chooses not to throw it to him like he did all the way down the field?
 

NoDak

UDFA
Messages
2,633
Reaction score
0
People like Sturm have written about how Witten stays in to block way too on plays close to the endzone. What, you think Witten is open in the endzone and Romo just chooses not to throw it to him like he did all the way down the field?

Not to mention, Romo looks for Witten all the time outside the redzone. Are we to believe he just forgets about his BFF down there? That he wouldn't want to get him TDs? That's the coaching/play calling.
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
57,895
Reaction score
8,668
People like Sturm have written about how Witten stays in to block way too often on plays close to the endzone. What, you think Witten is open in the endzone and Romo just chooses not to throw it to him like he did all the way down the field?

Any amount of plays where he stays in to block in the redzone is stupid IMO, but there are still plenty of times he was in the pattern and for whatever reason, didn't get the ball thrown his way.
 

Genghis Khan

Cheerleader
Messages
78
Reaction score
0
Maye their teams win more games bc touchdowns are worth points and points help you win games :O

Seriously? You are putting the fate of Super Bowls on the TEs.

The Cowboys would've won in 07 and 09 if it wasn't for that damn slacker Jason Witten holding them back.

:lol Come on.
 
Messages
46,859
Reaction score
5
I'm looking forward to seeing JJ Wilcox and Lance Dunbar. Two guys I'm not really high on but have been getting rave reviews from coaches.

Pretty sure I know more than them, being a forum administrator and all.

Also want to see some of these young linebackers.
 
Top Bottom