2011 Mel Kiper Jr. Invitational Report Card....

[SixisBetter]

I think New England did the best because of its trading, really nice job by the GM.

He came in 2nd on my scorecard,but it was mighty close.

But it was because of that trade,yeah.

 

[bvhawkeye]

I figured that I'd get a lower half grade because I gave up my first next year.
I thought the Jags had 2 immediate needs. Pass rushers and Safety's.
I traded up from 16 to 10 hoping that Robert Quinn or Marcel Dareus would slip to me. When that didn't happen I tried to trade back down.
Thought I had a shot at a couple of trade back downs that didn't pan out. Came down to Aldon Smith and Cameron Jordan with my high first. Took Smith because he's a much better pass rusher.
With the second first rounder I got from the Seahawks, I originally planned to take Rahim Moore at Safety. But when I saw Clayborn available I had to take him Clayborn starting opposite Kampman at DE and put Smith at OLB and I feel my pass rush problem is solved.
That left me with some holes, but I still think that a good D will stop a good O in the NFL. "If they can't score on you, then they can't beat you."

 

[bvhawkeye]

I don't like Akeem Ayers at all. And I don't like Thomas at all either. I did think Bailey was a great pick...

 

[Cr122]

I don't like Akeem Ayers at all. And I don't like Thomas at all either. I did think Bailey was a great pick...

I was kidding about my post, bvhawkeye. lol

I don't care if I got a bad grade.

 

[bvhawkeye]

I sort of assumed that. But I wanted you to know why anyway...

 

[Cr122]

I sort of assumed that. But I wanted you to know why anyway...

That's okay we will never know the outcome for at least a couple of years from now.

 

[MichaelWinicki]

My grades...


Mock draft grades...

Mel Kiper Jr. Grades...

Carolina Panthers 6
Denver Broncos 6
Buffalo Bills 5
Cincinnati Bengals 4
Arizona Cardinals 6
Cleveland Browns 6
San Francisco 49ers 5
Tennessee Titans 6
New Orleans Saints 5
Jacksonville Jaguars 6
Baltimore Ravens 4
Minnesota Vikings 4
Detroit Lions 6
St. Louis Rams 5
Miami Dolphins 3
Washington Redskins 4
San Diego Chargers 6
New York Giants 5
Tampa Bay Buccaneers 6
Kansas City Chiefs 6
Indianapolis Colts 6
Philadelphia Eagles 4
Dallas Cowboys -
Houston Texans 7
Atlanta Falcons 5
Chicago Bears 5
New York Jets 4
Pittsburgh Steelers 6
Green Bay Packers 5
Oakland Raiders 3
New England Patriots 6

Biggest Reach Ryan Mallett
Biggest Steal Jabaal Sheard

 

[Cr122]

Boy, Winicki is a stickler.

 

[marionbarberthe4th]

I'm going to post my grades too (not that anyone will really care)

Dallas-6
NY Giants-6
Philadelphia-5
Washington-2

Alright suck my dick for real. Got a top QB, WR, and a top 15-20 rated DL and I was given only 2 picks to start with


****ing Cowboys homers. Im defecting

 

[MichaelWinicki]

Boy, Winicki is a stickler.

Yeah I am... I admit that.

I also start with a "5" and then work up or down from there.

I just think it takes a super-duper spectacular draft to merit anything more than a 7 or a really bad draft to get lower than a 4.

 

[Cr122]

Alright suck my dick for real. Got a top QB, WR, and a top 15-20 rated DL and I was given only 2 picks to start with


****ing Cowboys homers. Im defecting

lol

 

[cmd34]

The Grades I sent in.

Cowboys -7
Giants - 6
Eagles - 0 (he flaked)
Redskins - 6
Bears - 7
Lions - 7
Vikings -5
Falcons - 6
Panthers - 1 (he would have set his franchise back a decade)
Saints -7
Cardinals - 5
49ers -8
Seahawks -8
Bills -7
Patriots - 9
Bengals -8
Browns - 8
Texans - 8
Jaguars -4
Titans -8
Broncos -7
Chargers - 7

 

[Sheik]

Most of you guys are now on my shit list after seeing my grades. Don't respond to this post. Just soak it in.

 

[MichaelWinicki]

Most of you guys are now on my shit list after seeing my grades. Don't respond to this post. Just soak it in.

lol

 

[bvhawkeye]

Alright suck my dick for real. Got a top QB, WR, and a top 15-20 rated DL and I was given only 2 picks to start with


****ing Cowboys homers. Im defecting

TOP QUARTERBACK??? Only in your F**king dreams bubba!!!

 

[marionbarberthe4th]

TOP QUARTERBACK??? Only in your F**king dreams bubba!!!

Wait til we meet in person!



Teams without a quarterback need to take a quarterback. You have no shot without one


Dont let your Todd McSchay love infect your brain. Locker is the shit

 

[bvhawkeye]

Alright suck my dick for real. Got a top QB, WR, and a top 15-20 rated DL and I was given only 2 picks to start with


****ing Cowboys homers. Im defecting

TOP RECEIVER??? I don't know what you've been smoking, but I'll bet it's illegal in Arkansas!!!

 

[bvhawkeye]

McShay and every other person that evaluates the draft. Just so you know, Locker also got my vote as biggest reach...

 

[SixisBetter]

I will post my grades,for $500.00 dollars cash,each,in my hand before I type a character.

Other than that,just assume I voted close to board average,and be at peace.

 

[marionbarberthe4th]

Reach around maybe you ****ing homo