2011 Mel Kiper Jr. Invitational Report Card....

[sbk92]

My grades.....


Dallas 9
NYG 7
Phil 6
Wash 5

Chi 8
Det 7
GB DCU
Minn 6

Atl 6
Car 2
NO 7
TB DCU

Ariz 8
SF 8
Sea 7
St.L DCU

Buf 9
Mia DCU
NE 9
NYJ DCU

Bal 6
Cin 6
Cle 7
Pitt DCU

Hou 9
Ind DCU
Jac 7
Tenn 6

Den 6
KC DCU
Oak DCU
SD ME

 

[sbk92]

I never thought I find a dude that made me respect Hostile again. At least he actually knows what he's talking about. You two do have the whole self-importance thing in common though.

Tell me again how cornerbacks don't matter in a pass-happy NFL? It's one of the dumbest things I've ever seen anyone who pretends to know football say. So entertain me clown.

I'm not going to tell you anything. You're whining and crying about a mock draft grade.

I just simply pointed out that all the people who thought you sucked were right.

 

[sbk92]

Frankly,I'm okay with my grade.

I would have given myself a 6.5-6.75.Drafting at 19 with no movement up in any round,I fully expected to have only an average draft,that's what I got.

No steals,no horrible reaches.

Didn't deserve an 8 or a 4,IMO.

And had myself a grand old time.

Nobody should care. Other than maybe the bragging rights to say you won.

But we always look back on it a few years later to see who really won. Could easily be you.

I've won this thing with a class that ended up not so good and I've lost it with a class that ended up being great.

 

[cmd34]

I'm not going to tell you anything. You're whining and crying about a mock draft grade.

I just simply pointed out that all the people who thought you sucked were right.

Cool. Not whining about anything. Didn't like the system you ran. It was flawed. I've ran and participated in mocks where the person running it didn't pick and it's my opinion they were better. I was joking when I was criticizing my grade and then you chimed in. I thought it was crazy that someone gave the Titans and Bengals mock a 1 and to me, the grading was flawed.

It's cool. I'm done. Still like 99% of the posters here. I just won't be participating in anything you have anything to do with. I think you're a clown and I'm mad at myself that I've wasted the last 20 minutes talking to a mentally challenged jackass. Peace.

 

[Midswat]

Seriously guys?

 

[Midswat]

I will say this about making physical threats to sbk.

He and I met up a few years ago over a disagreement. And while I did in fact beat the living shit out of him, it wasn't easy. He's pretty scrappy.

Be forewarned.

 

[SixisBetter]

I will say this about making physical threats to sbk.

He and I met up a few years ago over a disagreement. And while I did in fact beat the living shit out of him, it wasn't easy. He's pretty scrappy.

Be forewarned.

Props to you.

Word on the street is he is very polite about helping you find misplaced body parts after the scuffle.

 

[sbk92]

Cool. Not whining about anything. Didn't like the system you ran. It was flawed. I've ran and participated in mocks where the person running it didn't pick and it's my opinion they were better. I was joking when I was criticizing my grade and then you chimed in. I thought it was crazy that someone gave the Titans and Bengals mock a 1 and to me, the grading was flawed.

It's cool. I'm done. Still like 99% of the posters here. I just won't be participating in anything you have anything to do with. I think you're a clown and I'm mad at myself that I've wasted the last 20 minutes talking to a mentally challenged jackass. Peace.

Yeah, you're not pissed or anything. Clearly that's the case.

 

[sbk92]

He's an idiot. I knew it way before this when he's giving me his cell phone number like I'm his best friend.

It's can't be that nobody who voted thought he had a top class. It has to be the voting was flawed. And the commish ran a team. And there were site run teams. Stuff like that.

 

[cmd34]

I'll let you get the last word after this because I know that's important to you but I sent you my number so that I wouldn't be responsible for holding up the mock. I've ran these before and I know how easy it is for one person to hold it up and jack things up. If that makes me an idiot then so be it.

I called out your grading system and you got all defensive and started insulting me. I 100% believe that these things run best with neutral commissioners. I am not the least bit worried that I didn't "win" a mock draft. I'm not pissed. I just don't like you and think this board or any board is a better place without you.

 

[Deuce511]

I'm glad cmd seems up in arms about the grading. It makes me feel like my victory feel even more sweet.

Props to sbk for running it, I thought he did an excellent job keeping it smooth and getting it done in under 2 days. I've been apart of them when they go 3+.

 

[sbk92]

Oh yeah. It's me. You're not pissed that everybody gave you a bad grade. You're just pissed because I ran it. You decided to wait until the report card was in to announce that.

I'm not interested in any last word. Especially with a guy who's apparently as tough as you are. I fear our first meeting. It won't be pretty for me.

It's the last punch I'm worried about. Have mercy.

 

[sbk92]

I'm glad cmd seems up in arms about the grading. It makes me feel like my victory feel even more sweet.

Props to sbk for running it, I thought he did an excellent job keeping it smooth and getting it done in under 2 days. I've been apart of them when they go 3+.

You only won because the grading was flawed.

He's not just trying to insult me. He's insulting everybody who voted. Because everybody agreed on the top classes and he wasn't one of them. At least 5 or 6 others gave him a worst grade than I did.

He's not wrong. We just voted wrong. Had somebody else ran the draft it would all be different.

 

[Midswat]

I agree that the voting was flawed.

Had it not been, the Texans would've won.

 

[bvhawkeye]

Next time ill do better, first year doing this, next time ill stand pat.

Ahhh, to hell with standing pat. Half the fun of the draft is talking trades with the other GM's...

 

[bvhawkeye]

I don't think he won because of all the picks he had. I think he won because of the trade.

EXACTLY. That trade was incredible. But I also really like his picks...

 

[SixisBetter]

Ahhh, to hell with standing pat. Half the fun of the draft is talking trades with the other GM's...

Sure.If I hadn't been convinced I'd get what the Giants needed at 19,I'd have dealt with you.

 

[Cr122]

I think New England did the best because of its trading, really nice job by the GM.

 

[bvhawkeye]

I'm going to post my grades too (not that anyone will really care)

Dallas-6
NY Giants-6
Philadelphia-5
Washington-2

Chicago-8
Detroit-6
Minnesota-7

Atlanta-7
Carolina-8
New Orleans-5

Arizona-6
San Francisco-6
Seattle-7

Buffalo-8.5
New England-9

Baltimore-6
Cincinnati-8
Cleveland-8.5

Houston-9
Tennessee-8.5

Denver-7
San Diego-8.5

There were a couple of DCU drafts I thought were really good. The Chiefs and the Rams.

 

[Cr122]

A F'KING 5!!!!!!!!! JESUS CHRIST MAN ARE YOU F' KING STUPID???