sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
Posted by jellis at 1/20/2011 5:41 PM CST on truebluefanclub.com


Now that Paul Pasqualoni is at UConn and it appears Reggie Herring is headed for Houston, the Cowboys have only a couple coaches under contract defensively for Rob Ryan to work with.

The new defensive coordinator could want to let go of secondary coach Dave Campo and/or safeties coach Brett Maxie to bring in his own guys. But is that what should happen? Should Jason Garrett leave it to Ryan to bring in whoever he likes for the defensive staff?

Garrett has final say on all coaching staff matters, but because most of his background is on the offensive side, he may be tempted to let Ryan pick his guys. If it's done that way, the newly-promoted head coach may risk presiding over a staff of coaches who have divided loyalties.

During his eight-game stint as interim coach, Garrett made it clear he had convictions about certain things, and was interested in having in hand in the defense to some extent, sitting in on all of their meetings in addition to those on offense. He will likely continue to do the same, but how will new coaches respond to that, especially if they believes it was Ryan and Ryan alone who brought them to town?

Garrett has been around the league and been a coach long enough to know of some pretty good candidates for position coaches. Unless he's ready to draw a line of chalk across the locker room and coaching department again, maybe he should insist on retaining a guy or two from the current staff, and bringing in another defensive assistant of his choosing.
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
58,583
Reaction score
9,065
And of course if Garrett alone handpicked all the defensive assistants, we'd be reading about "Garrett's ego is compromising the new defensive coordinator by not allowing him to pick guys that can implement his scheme"
 

Bob Sacamano

All-Pro
Messages
26,436
Reaction score
3
It's not unusual for a new head coach, let alone a new coordinator, to bring in their hand-picked staffs. So I don't know what the big deal is. Of course Garrett is an offensive guy, so while I'm sure he knows some good defensive coordinators, and will give his input in the construction of his defensive staff, I bet he defers to Ryan in a lot of his decisions. If not most all of them. You want your coordinators to be as comfortable as they can with the people they'll be working with for a year or years.
 
Messages
46,859
Reaction score
5
Garrett needs to let Ryan bring in guys he's comfortable with, and knows Ryans defense in and out, and what is expected from each position in every situation.

I don't buy the "divided loyalty" nonsense.

The only risk with that is, when Ryan gets a head coaching gig after we win the Super Bowl in 2011, we're going to have to bring in an entirely new defensive staff, as Ryans guys will likely go with him to his new team.
 

Plymkr

2
Messages
2,126
Reaction score
0
I think both should collaberate on the defense, but, IMO, Ryan should have last say.
 

Cythim

2
Messages
3,919
Reaction score
0
Let Ryan pick with Garrett providing oversight on guys he doesn't think will fit into the culture he wants to create among the coaches.
 

VAcowboy

Practice Squad
Messages
187
Reaction score
0
If a head coach has to pick position coaches because he's afraid a coordinator will build a staff disloyal and disruptive to the team, he has hired the wrong coordinator.
 
Messages
46,859
Reaction score
5
Let Ryan pick with Garrett providing oversight on guys he doesn't think will fit into the culture he wants to create among the coaches.

If a head coach has to pick position coaches because he's afraid a coordinator will build a staff disloyal and disruptive to the team, he has hired the wrong coordinator.

applause.gif
 
Top Bottom