dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
57,933
Reaction score
8,708
Just my opinions:

Team MVP- He started out kinda shakey this yr and had a couple bad moments vs the Jets and Lions, but Romo is definitely the teams MVP this year. Without him we probably end up with a top 5 pick

Offensive MVP- Romo probably deserves this too, but since I gave him the overall MVP I'll pick another guy here. Going with Laurent Robinson. Came in late, got cut once and had to play just about every WR position at one time or another due to injuries to Austin and Bryant. Earned alot of Romo's confidence and ended up with a really solid year. Ended up with 54 catches, 858 yds (almost 16.0 yds per catch) and 11 tds. Didnt drop many passes either. Off the top of my head I only recall 1 or 2.

Defensive MVP- Had Lee not gotten hurt, no telling what his year would have looked like. It was still great. But this team is nothing defensively with Demarcus Ware. If he'd have went down we'd have probably given up 30-40 pts a week. Not as many game changing plays (the strip sacks) as past years, but saw more double/triple teaming than probably any other defensive player in the league. Year in and year out puts up huge numbers despite other teams OL's being able to do whatever they want in terms of holding with almost no fear of ever being called for it. Refs show no hesitation giving Ware the phantom offsides call, but he almost never gets the holding calls no matter how obvious they are (see Trent Williams MNF)

Best rookie- This was a really good rookie class. Had Demarco Murray not gotten hurt we might have made the playoffs and his numbers probably would have warranted some consideration for rookie of the year (probably wouldnt have won, but would have gotten some votes). Dan Bailey was exceptional as a rookie kicker. But Tyron Smith was a borderline probowl calibar player almost from day one and should be a fixture in that game for years to come. Will move to LT next yr and with a year in our weight program and more technique refinement, could be a monster for years to come. I think the future is pretty bright for Bruce Carter, Kevin Kowalski and Punter Chris Jones as well. Dwayne Harris improved and was a late season boost to the return game.

Most surprising player (positive)- Probably Dan Bailey. They spent all training camp trying to find someone else, but in the end he was far superior to anything else and was close to a probowl performer as a rookie. Won or tied a number of close games with pressure kicks. Showed good range and had 24 touchbacks.

Most disappointing player- Probably a few prime candidates here. Doug Free had a really solid first year and a half as a starter, but he had some really poor games this year after getting a big contract. Newman was awful in December. Abe Elam was terrible in pass coverage all year, and probably made fewer plays than any other regular starting safety in the NFL. Certainly had the fewest passed defensed (ZERO) and got no ints. I'm going with Anthony Spencer though. After getting 3 sacks and being pretty active in the first 3 games, ended up with only 6 sacks and in a majority of games was invisible despite seeing only single blocking. Was moved around alot and still did next to nothing. It was a contract year too. His failure to take off as a pass rusher opp Ware really crippled the defense IMO, especially in terms of stopping teams on 3rd and long. Should be replaced for 2012 and I would only resign him if its a bargain basement deal.

Best game- Blowout win vs Buffalo. At the time Buffalo was starting to tail off a little, but they were still considered one of the leagues surprise good teams when we played them.

Worst game- Blowout loss at Philly. Team didnt even look competitive that night.
 
Messages
2,310
Reaction score
0
Sean Lee was our defensive MVP, no doubt. He had over twice as many turnovers as Ware, 7 pass breakups, and 10 stuffs, not to mention twice as many tackles as Ware. Ware got the sacks, but Lee was overall more important to this D imo.

Also, Spencer as the biggest disappointment just shows how some people don't understand what he brings to this team. It really is all about sacks to some people.

Aside from those two, i like your other picks though.
 
Last edited:
Messages
46,859
Reaction score
5
You couldn't go wrong with either Ware or Lee as DMVP's. They are far and away the best defensive players we have. I'd give it to Ware though. To get 19.5 sacks is incredible. Especially when no one else is helping him out.

Most guys with 10+ sacks have someone opposite them who pressure the QB towards their side. Ware doesn't have that.
 
Messages
2,310
Reaction score
0
You couldn't go wrong with either Ware or Lee as DMVP's. They are far and away the best defensive players we have. I'd give it to Ware though. To get 19.5 sacks is incredible. Especially when no one else is helping him out.

Most guys with 10+ sacks have someone opposite them who pressure the QB towards their side. Ware doesn't have that.

I wouldn't say most guys.. Spencer got as much pressure as most guys opposite the sacks leaders this year. I don't think the sacks outweight Lee's overall contributions to this D this year though.
 

DoomsdayDefense

Practice Squad
Messages
249
Reaction score
0
I'd give team and offensive MVP to Romo. No question about it. Robinson can have most suprising player though.
 
Messages
2,310
Reaction score
0
I'd give team and offensive MVP to Romo. No question about it. Robinson can have most suprising player though.

We all probably would do the same, im thinking he just wanted to spread out the awards so he picked someone other than Tony for OMVP.
 

Mr.Po

2
Messages
2,711
Reaction score
0
I'd give Lee Defensive MVP. Not enough consistency out of Ware in big games. Sacks are important but it's becoming a little overated stat IMO in todays game. In this pass first ask questions later brand of football that is dominating the NFL, sack totals should be escalating with QB's dropping back 35-50 times a game.
 

cmd34

Pro Bowler
Messages
11,877
Reaction score
119
No votes for Sensabaugh? He clearly had an impact to earn a 5-year extension. ??
 

superpunk

Pro Bowler
Messages
11,003
Reaction score
0
Not really disappointed in Spencer. He's shown what he is, a mediocre player who will never really change or impact a game.

I was enormously disappointed in Doug Free and Terrence Newman, though. Free looked shaky all year, and Newman went from competent corner to maybe the worst starter on the team.

Semi-disappointed in Dez, tbh. I really expected huge things from him this year, so that's probably just a function of my unrealistic expectations. But I was looking for more than 60 some yards per game from him this season, especially once Miles went down.
 
Messages
1,274
Reaction score
0
Not really disappointed in Spencer. He's shown what he is, a mediocre player who will never really change or impact a game.
Spencer has underperformed thus far in his career. He was a highly thought of pass rusher coming out of college and he still has yet to eclipse 6 sacks in a season.
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
57,933
Reaction score
8,708
Also, Spencer as the biggest disappointment just shows how some people don't understand what he brings to this team. It really is all about sacks to some people.

.

Its hard to understand because most weeks he doesnt bring anything. It isnt all about sacks. Getting consistent pressure and knocking the QB down are just as important, and Spencer was invisible far too much.

Its also why he'll likely be replaced here.
 
Messages
2,310
Reaction score
0
Its hard to understand because most weeks he doesnt bring anything. It isnt all about sacks. Getting consistent pressure and knocking the QB down are just as important, and Spencer was invisible far too much.

Its also why he'll likely be replaced here.

He had more QB hits this year than any SOLB expect Clay Matthews.. try again.

You can all sit here and talk about how much he sucks as much as you want, but when you look at the numbers, it shows he's been one of the best SOLB's in the league this year, and really the past 3 years in terms of all around production.

Had 15 QB hits, 12 tackles for loss this year, 66 tackles, 6 sacks, 4 FF's. He was one of the top 5 SOLB's in the league this year. Saying he's average or he sucks is a joke.. and a claim that has no evidence to back it up.
 
Messages
10,636
Reaction score
0
Offensive MVP- Romo probably deserves this too, but since I gave him the overall MVP I'll pick another guy here. Going with Laurent Robinson. Came in late, got cut once and had to play just about every WR position at one time or another due to injuries to Austin and Bryant. Earned alot of Romo's confidence and ended up with a really solid year. Ended up with 54 catches, 858 yds (almost 16.0 yds per catch) and 11 tds. Didnt drop many passes either. Off the top of my head I only recall 1 or 2.



Can people shut up about this journeyman?
 

Hoofbite

Draft Pick
Messages
4,231
Reaction score
0
Spencer is a slacker. Plain and simple. Fuck him.

He's lazy and has played nowhere near the level he was playing at to close out the 2009 season. He admitted to quitting last year and will take plays off all the time.

Give me Ahmad Brooks.
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
57,933
Reaction score
8,708
He had more QB hits this year than any SOLB expect Clay Matthews.. try again.

You can all sit here and talk about how much he sucks as much as you want, but when you look at the numbers, it shows he's been one of the best SOLB's in the league this year, and really the past 3 years in terms of all around production.

Had 15 QB hits, 12 tackles for loss this year, 66 tackles, 6 sacks, 4 FF's. He was one of the top 5 SOLB's in the league this year. Saying he's average or he sucks is a joke.. and a claim that has no evidence to back it up.

Right. I'm sure thats why they are falling all over themselves at VR to get him signed to a contract extension, because his production is so critical to our defense.
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
57,933
Reaction score
8,708
Offensive MVP- Romo probably deserves this too, but since I gave him the overall MVP I'll pick another guy here. Going with Laurent Robinson. Came in late, got cut once and had to play just about every WR position at one time or another due to injuries to Austin and Bryant. Earned alot of Romo's confidence and ended up with a really solid year. Ended up with 54 catches, 858 yds (almost 16.0 yds per catch) and 11 tds. Didnt drop many passes either. Off the top of my head I only recall 1 or 2.



Can people shut up about this journeyman?

Didnt play like a "journeyman" this year for us.
 

LAZARUS_LOGAN

Pro Bowler
Messages
14,639
Reaction score
207
He had more QB hits this year than any SOLB expect Clay Matthews.. try again.

You can all sit here and talk about how much he sucks as much as you want, but when you look at the numbers, it shows he's been one of the best SOLB's in the league this year, and really the past 3 years in terms of all around production.

Had 15 QB hits, 12 tackles for loss this year, 66 tackles, 6 sacks, 4 FF's. He was one of the top 5 SOLB's in the league this year. Saying he's average or he sucks is a joke.. and a claim that has no evidence to back it up.



BNot sure as to why you are trying to defned Spencer. Old ass Greg Ellis---at the tail end of his career, managed to put up double-digit sack numbers for the first time of his career, playing opposite of Ware. Ellis was always good for about 8 sacks a year, and that was without him having anyone dominant opposite of him, until Ware. Spencer has done no mroe than 6 sacks. That's unacceptable.
 

Hoofbite

Draft Pick
Messages
4,231
Reaction score
0
So, that Anthony Spencer article that is being referred to forgets to mention Connor Barwin.

11.5 sacks. Instead they mentioned the guy on the other side.

Simple mistake I suppose.
 

Sheik

All-Pro
Messages
24,809
Reaction score
5
Here's my thing with Spencer. You would have to upgrade 3 positions to make him a better player, IMO. If you replaced Anthony Spencer with someone that could get to the QB regularly, you make the whole defense better. Corners, safeties and ILBs especially.
 
Top Bottom