bbgun

Administrator
Messages
15,172
Reaction score
2,363
He's on IR you grouchy shit. He isnt hogging up a roster spot for somebody that CAN play.

He doesn't count shit against the cap. He looked like he has talent the brief amount of time he was actually on the field but nobody has seen enough of him to know for sure. Nothing wrong with storing him away till next offseason. If he stinks or cant stay on the field then, he'll be gone.

Yes, that seems to be a recurring theme. He's the beneficiary of favoritism based on his draft round. Had McSurdy tweaked his foot, he would not be sipping pina coladas on IR.
 
Messages
8,660
Reaction score
0
That's the mentality that has paralyzed this team for a decade and a half.

We take a mid-round flyer on a small school guy hoping he develops into the next hidden gem, and hold on to him until we have no other option but to cut him. If the guy shows something on the practice field, he's secured 3 years of being with the club. Who cares if they do anything in games?

Meanwhile, the front office wonders why our depth is shit.
 
Messages
6,827
Reaction score
1
Matt Johnson is on twitter telling people not to use the word "******". His boss must find it offensive...
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
58,625
Reaction score
9,079
Yes, that seems to be a recurring theme. He's the beneficiary of favoritism based on his draft round. Had McSurdy tweaked his foot, he would not be sipping pina coladas on IR.

Matt Johnson appeared to be vastly more talented than Caleb McSurdy, and he plays a position we are not set in stone at like MLB.

I keep hearing crap like "they kept him because he was a Jerry pick" but the fact is they've cut other draft picks in recent years.

McSurdy was also a "Jerry pick" by the way.

They IR'd Johnson because they want to give him another chance next year. Cost them basically nothing to do it.
 

bbgun

Administrator
Messages
15,172
Reaction score
2,363
Uh huh. Remind me again why Isiah Stanback hung around as long as he did? Because he was a 4th rounder. To reiterate, this has nothing to do with ability/potential and everything to do with Jerry's ego.
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
58,625
Reaction score
9,079
Uh huh. Remind me again why Isiah Stanback hung around as long as he did? Because he was a 4th rounder. To reiterate, this has nothing to do with ability/potential and everything to do with Jerry's ego.

ok
 

junk

UDFA
Messages
2,719
Reaction score
0
I hate to say it......but I actually agree with dbair here. I threw up in my mouth a little bit saying that.

Compare Johnson to Arkin. If Johnson was hogging up a roster space, then by all means it is worth complaining about it. As it is, he's on IR, so who cares if they hold on to him and bring him to camp with the other 92 people going to camp?

I agree the odds are against him ever contributing, but it isn't like they are keeping him on the roster, keeping him inactive every week and hoping he somehow develops. Be more pissed about Arkin.
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
58,625
Reaction score
9,079
Be more pissed about Arkin.

I wasn't thrilled they kept Arkin, but unlike a guy like Weems Arkin did seem to play ok at times during preseason, although I thought they might keep Kowalski instead because he can play G & C. Also wasn't sure what Frampton did to earn a roster spot. I think Weems, Frampton and Arkin are 3 guys who might be here today, but might not be here in a week or two.

By the way, did they re-sign Armstrong? DC.com has him back on the roster. All the other recent moves are on there, but he is listed again.
 

cmd34

Pro Bowler
Messages
11,877
Reaction score
119
By the way, did they re-sign Armstrong? DC.com has him back on the roster. All the other recent moves are on there, but he is listed again.

No, whoever does the roster sucks. They are always late or wrong. Armstrong was still on it and Livings still showed active last time I checked.
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
58,625
Reaction score
9,079
No, whoever does the roster sucks. They are always late or wrong. Armstrong was still on it and Livings still showed active last time I checked.

They have Livings on IR now, and the two new guys are on the roster.

But Armstrong is still on there too.
 
Top Bottom