Messages
4,604
Reaction score
0
Why not Johnny Manziel to the Cowboys?
Posted Friday, Apr. 18, 2014
BY CLARENCE E. HILL JR.

Robert F. Kennedy often gets the credit, but it was George Bernard Shaw who was the originator of this quote: “There are those that look at things the way they are, and ask why? I dream of things that never were, and ask why not?”

So in regard to the Cowboys and the upcoming NFL Draft, why not Texas A&M lightning rod Johnny Manziel?

Why not Johnny Freaking Football, or JFF for short?

There is no question that improving the defense has been the focus of the Cowboys’ off-season, let alone the NFL Draft.

Owner Jerry Jones and vice president Stephen Jones have said as much on a number of occasions over the last few months.

They have followed that up by concentrating on defense during this past week’s pre-draft visits.

The Cowboys need help up front with the departures of Pro Bowlers DeMarcus Ware and Jason Hatcher to go along with the iffy status of former Pro Bowler Anthony Spencer, who has yet to recover from microfracture knee surgery.

To that end, the Cowboys paraded a host of top national defensive line prospects through the team’s headquarters earlier this week.

Those prospects included Pittsburgh defensive tackle Aaron Donald, Missouri defensive end Kony Ealy, UCLA linebacker Anthony Barr, Florida State defensive tackle Timmy Jernigan, Boise State defensive end Demarcus Lawrence, Arizona State defensive end Davon Coleman, West Virginia defensive end Will Clarke, Florida defensive tackle Dominique Easley and Oregon State defensive end Scott Crichton.

It all makes sense.

It’s right.

And it’s a correct plan of action when you consider the Cowboys’ struggles on defense the past two years.

But when it comes to the Cowboys’ draft, history has taught us that there are three rules to live by:

• Drafting the best available player.

• Drafting for need.

• And WJW, or Whatever Jerry Wants, which usually comes with a wow factor.

And this is where JFF comes into play.

The Cowboys most certainly won’t move up into the top of the draft to get Manziel.

They have too many needs and it would cost too much.

But let Manziel start to slide and Jones’ eyes will start to widen. Then, all bets are off.

From a pure football sense, there is no need to take a quarterback in the first round.

Tony Romo is entering just the second year of his $108 million contract extension and coming off one of the best seasons of his career.

The Cowboys are in a win-now mode with Romo and need to find him as much help as possible rather than drafting his eventual replacement.

But Jones is also in the business of selling tickets and selling hope to an increasingly disillusioned fan base.

To be honest, the Cowboys have done nothing so far this off-season to make anyone think this team will be better than the 8-8 squads of the past three years.

In fact, they are actually worse on paper, though they are clinging to the hope that healthy unknown players will be more productive than unhealthy stars.

More productive is one thing. Being good enough to make the playoffs and an eventual run to the Super Bowl is another.

You need great players to win and, to be honest, the only impact players on defense the Cowboys are eyeing with the 16th pick are Donald and Barr.

And there is no guarantee that either will still be on the board when it’s the Cowboys’ turn to pick.

That’s a definite certainty if Manziel starts to slide, opening the door for a possible match made at JerryWorld and made for JerryWorld.

Manziel was not among the Cowboys’ pre-draft visits.

But he already has a relationship with Jones and the Cowboys that include his much-publicized visit to the owner’s suite during the NCAA Final Four.

What’s also true is the Cowboys have quietly gone about their business doing their homework on Manziel. They have talked to his people. They have talked to people close to him.

There is no question that he is on their radar.
And this is not even considering any concern about Romo, who is coming off back surgeries the past two off-seasons.

Cowboys legendary quarterback Troy Aikman — whose own Hall of Fame career was cut short by back issues at 34, the same age Romo will be next season — expressed concerns of his own in a recent interview on the team’s website.

“Two back surgeries in less than a year at his age, I would be a bit concerned,” Aikman said. “I’m hopeful that he’s able to come back — everybody is. This team won’t be the same if he’s not able to. I anticipate that he will come back. But to say that, ‘Hey, he’s ahead of schedule and everything’s going fine,’ I’m not sure how you can really measure that here in April.”

Time will tell on that, and the Cowboys expressed nothing but confidence and optimism over Romo’s rehab and recovery.

But it is another thing to consider.

Again, the Cowboys are and should be focused on improving the defense.

But if Manziel starts to slide, Jones will not only be dreaming but asking, “Why not?”
 

jnday

UDFA
Messages
2,680
Reaction score
0
Jerry drafting Johnny Football is a dream situation for me. The fan reaction would be comic gold. I guess he could also play QB , but the pleasure that I would get from seeing Johnny drafted would give me years if entertainment. I am hoping and praying for it.
 

ThoughtExperiment

Quality Starter
Messages
9,906
Reaction score
3
Only bad thing is it would add more attention without winning to the team. We could keep slopping around at 8-8 and it would put even more money in Jerry's pocket.
 
Messages
3,455
Reaction score
0
That would get me excited to be a Cowboys fan. Manziel will win on his own, even with a shit defense. Excited is also an understatement. I would freak out.
 

jnday

UDFA
Messages
2,680
Reaction score
0
Fuck it. I'm on board.

Let the circus continue around this once proud franchise.

That's the spirit. This team sucks anyway without hope if improving. As Jerry said, be entertained.
 
Messages
2,329
Reaction score
11
That would get me excited to be a Cowboys fan. Manziel will win on his own, even with a shit defense. Excited is also an understatement. I would freak out.
I don't understand this, and not directly at you Everlxxx, but Romo has basically been a "keep the play alive" playmaker for many years. Yes, he thinks he does not have to run the ball for positive yardage anymore, but he is playing this offense as well as could be expected given that he has very little help from the coaching staff (they refuse to commit to running the ball with a lead even though there is great risk of a three and out or a stopping of a clock, and even worse, detrimental outcomes like interceptions, sacks or fumbles). His head coach demands that the scheme be managed by Romo based on the defense, with such rigidity that when the offensive line was considered the weakest part of the team 3 years ago, the playcalling did not change to adjust to the weakness; instead there was a team-record 648 attempts. For a short passing scheme, there might be some strategy here but the "vertical scheme" that Jason has issued, the routes all have some adjustment to the distance and position of the defenders. So just in the math of how much time a seven step drop affords against the 5 seconds that an average speed rusher or blitzer needs to get into the backfield facing a typical O-line, Romo and the time/ball possession was being put at great risk on every play that a nationally recognized weakness of the Cowboys that year. Even Belichick who runs an offense with variable receiver tree routes used a mixture of Faulk/Dillon and what Steve Young diagnosed as a WCO scheme to protect Brady in the early years. So I ask, what is Manziel really going to be able accomplish without a coach who designs and directs the game to fit the strengths and weaknesses of the team. Right now, to me, Romo is the best shot if something drastic happens with the coaching philosophy and /or staff responsibilities. But without change (such that is not a continuation of the same ridiculous refurbish with Linehan), any QB who is introduced will be at risk more than a success.
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
58,539
Reaction score
9,040
I don't understand this, and not directly at you Everlxxx, but Romo has basically been a "keep the play alive" playmaker for many years. Yes, he thinks he does not have to run the ball for positive yardage anymore, but he is playing this offense as well as could be expected given that he has very little help from the coaching staff (they refuse to commit to running the ball with a lead even though there is great risk of a three and out or a stopping of a clock, and even worse, detrimental outcomes like interceptions, sacks or fumbles). His head coach demands that the scheme be managed by Romo based on the defense, with such rigidity that when the offensive line was considered the weakest part of the team 3 years ago, the playcalling did not change to adjust to the weakness; instead there was a team-record 648 attempts. For a short passing scheme, there might be some strategy here but the "vertical scheme" that Jason has issued, the routes all have some adjustment to the distance and position of the defenders. So just in the math of how much time a seven step drop affords against the 5 seconds that an average speed rusher or blitzer needs to get into the backfield facing a typical O-line, Romo and the time/ball possession was being put at great risk on every play that a nationally recognized weakness of the Cowboys that year. Even Belichick who runs an offense with variable receiver tree routes used a mixture of Faulk/Dillon and what Steve Young diagnosed as a WCO scheme to protect Brady in the early years. So I ask, what is Manziel really going to be able accomplish without a coach who designs and directs the game to fit the strengths and weaknesses of the team. Right now, to me, Romo is the best shot if something drastic happens with the coaching philosophy and /or staff responsibilities. But without change (such that is not a continuation of the same ridiculous refurbish with Linehan), any QB who is introduced will be at risk more than a success.

LOL

some of this stuff is just fucking hilarious
 

BraveHeartFan

Spectator
Messages
36
Reaction score
0
If I were sold on Johnny Football I'd absolutely be all for it. The problem is that I'm really not sold on the kid and I'm not sure I'd want to take the risk.

I am pretty sure Dallas won't take that risk regardless but if they did I'd root for it to work out, obviously, because I don't generally get to wrapped up in rather the team drafts my pet cats or not.
 
Messages
46,859
Reaction score
5
There are some players who, regardless of talent, wouldn't succeed in Dallas.

Manzel is one of these guys. He needs a strong coaching staff, support system, and a low key atmosphere focused on football.

He'd get none of that here.
 

boozeman

Draft Pick
Messages
3,859
Reaction score
0
There are some players who, regardless of talent, wouldn't succeed in Dallas.

Manzel is one of these guys. He needs a strong coaching staff, support system, and a low key atmosphere focused on football.

He'd get none of that here.

I also think he would benefit from a small market team, like Cleveland or Jacksonville.

Him in Dallas would be huge, he'd be a rock star.
 
Messages
3,455
Reaction score
0
I think Manziel is going to be successful wherever he goes. If the Jags pick him, they will be in the playoffs in a year or two. He is a no-brainer #1 overall pick IMHO. Sure he needs to clean up his game and be a little more patient in the pocket but he does things on the field that no other quarterback can do. The way he throws on the run is on an elite superstar level.
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
58,539
Reaction score
9,040
I think Manziel is going to be successful wherever he goes. If the Jags pick him, they will be in the playoffs in a year or two. He is a no-brainer #1 overall pick IMHO. Sure he needs to clean up his game and be a little more patient in the pocket but he does things on the field that no other quarterback can do. The way he throws on the run is on an elite superstar level.

LOL
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
58,539
Reaction score
9,040
FWIW, Ed Turder is claiming if Manziel somehow slipped to 16, Dallas would definitely take him.

Now I'm more convinced than ever we have absolutely zero interest in the guy, which I am happy about.
 

Bob Sacamano

All-Pro
Messages
26,436
Reaction score
3
idk dbair, we've signed 2 Qbs. So there is definitely interest in finding some type of young QB.
 
Top Bottom