Creeper
UDFA
- Messages
- 2,034
- Reaction score
- 2,479
I have posted about this before. Some states have already eliminated the Castle Doctrine, not by passing laws but by changing the authority of prosecutors and courts to prosecute people for defending their property. In NJ, you will already be prosecuted for defending your property with a gun. If your home is invaded and your shoot the invaders you will have to go to court to prove your life was threatened, even though the Castle Doctrine exists in NJ. You have an obligation to retreat first and only if you can show a definitive threat to life or limb can you use lethal force.
If you think this is unusual, or not true, consider the two people in Missouri who brandished unloaded weapons when a BLM march passed through their private gated community. The couple, Mark and Patricia McCloskey, simply appeared on their front porch waving unloaded weapons as a warning to protesters not to do harm to their home or property. The McCloskeys were indicted on felony charges by a grand jury, but prosecutors reduced the charges to misdemeanors. The couple agreed to plead guilty to misdemeanor charges. I don't know if felony charges would have stood on appeal. The Castle Doctrine means nothing anymore in many states.