- Messages
- 58,920
- Reaction score
- 9,267
Jerry has a severe hard on for finding “the next Charles Haley”. He had the same hard on for “the next Novacek” too. That’s how we went up with Shante Carver, Kavika Pittman, and David LaFleur.
Carver was rated a 1st rd/early 2nd rd pick and LaFleur was rated the top TE by BLESTO that yr, and was actually rated a top-10 pick by their service (which at the time, most NFL teams used). Carver and LaFleur were both outstanding college players at top-schools and neither had any red-flags when we took them. Carver had 4 consecutive 10+ sack seasons at Arizona St.
LaFleur wasn't intended to be a "Novacek". He was far bigger and stronger than Novacek was. LaFleur was drafted because they did NEED a quality TE. The guy they drafted to be the next "Novacek" was Eric Bjornson, an athletic guy who had a similar build as Novacek. Bjornson was never more than a JAG though.
Carver's career was ruined by becoming an alcoholic, and LaFleur's was ruined by a degenerative back issue.
Pittman was clearly the worst pick of those 3, as we passed on Tony Brackens (a guy rated as a top-15 on our draft board that yr) and instead traded down, ending up with Pittman (massive bust) and Clay Shiver (also horrible) instead of Brackens, who was a really good player for awhile at a position we needed help at.
Revisionist history definitely takes over for a lot of people when looking back at drafts. Some players end up bad but are not bad picks at the time they are made. Neither Carver nor LaFleur were over-drafted for where they were rated coming out, although in hindsight neither was a good pick.