Messages
46,859
Reaction score
5
By David Moore , Staff Writer Contact David Mooreon Twitter:mad:DavidMooreDMN

The way the season ended for the Cowboys was a disappointment.

That doesn't make it a disappointing season.

Far from it. The Cowboys orchestrated the most dramatic turnaround in franchise history, their 13-3 record representing a nine-game improvement over the previous season. Dallas won the NFC East, sculpted the best record in the conference and captured the No. 1 seed.

Did that nudge the team past the divisional round for the first time in 21 years? No. But a thrilling 34-31 loss to Green Bay felt more like a beginning than the end for this group.

A stellar draft class, the rise of other young players and a strong veteran core led to the most unexpected season of Jerry Jones' ownership. Head coach Jason Garrett and his staff are taking the weekend off before getting back together to coach the Pro Bowl. Individual evaluations on this team will be conducted later.

Why wait? We've gotten the paperwork underway by picking up the performance evaluation forms lying around the office at The Dallas Morning News and filling in the blanks.

Needs Improvement (17)
Description: Frequently fails to meet performance expectations. Does not consistently perform to standards with respect to quality and quantity of work. Requires a high level of guidance, direction and motivation.

Dez Bryant, WR: The attention defensive coordinators pay Bryant creates space for the team's other receivers. But he caught just one pass in three games and was shut out in another. With 50 catches for 796 yards, he failed to rank in the top 50 in either category. His response to suffering a hairline fracture of his right tibial plateau -- he skipped the initial MRI and team meetings, fearing the worst -- was irresponsible.

Tyrone Crawford, DE: He plays hard. He plays hurt. He spent most of the season at left defensive end after being told he would finally get to focus on playing the three-technique at defensive tackle. But Crawford hasn't come close to performing to the level his contract dictates. Only one of his 4 1/2 sacks came in the final two months of the regular season.

DeMarcus Lawrence, DE: He began the season with a four-game suspension. He missed the final three games of the regular season nursing a back injury. He didn't do much in between. After leading the team with eight sacks the previous season, Lawrence finished with just one in 2016. Seven other defensive linemen finished with more tackles and three others finished with more quarterback pressures.

Others

Mark Sanchez, QB: Backup doesn't get many chances, but he has to be better than 9 of 17 for 85 yards with two interceptions and three sacks.

Brice Butler, WR: Deep threat who caught just seven balls for 122 yards in the final 10 games of the season.

Lucky Whitehead, WR/KR: Effective running the jet sweep. But caught only three passes as a receiver and didn't provide much pop in return game.

Gavin Escobar, TE: Team lost two tight ends to injury, and he still couldn't get on the field. Finished with just four catches for 30 yards.

Darren McFadden, RB: Injuries kept him out for all but three games, but averaged only 3.6 yards a carry when he did play.

Alfred Morris, RB: Got off to a good start as Ezekiel Elliott's backup but eventually lost that job to Darren McFadden.

Lance Dunbar, RB: A change-of-pace back who touched the ball only 25 times. He did score one touchdown.

Orlando Scandrick, CB: Struggled with injuries to both hamstrings and plantar fasciitis in coming back from ACL injury. Clearly wasn't himself.

Cedric Thornton, DT: Didn't have the impact the Cowboys anticipated after signing him as a free agent from Philadelphia.

Randy Gregory, DE: Played only two games because of suspension and picked up the first sack of his career, but his struggle with addiction puts his career in doubt.

Emmett Cleary, OL: Started one game late in the season and held up well, but still has to show he can land a spot in the league as a reserve.

Kavon Frazier, SS: Rarely saw the field as a backup safety but made a few plays on special teams.

Mark Nzeocha, LB: Made only one tackle on special teams, one fewer than punter Chris Jones.

Leon McFadden, CB: Got some time in the regular-season finale against Philadelphia. Otherwise, not much.

Probationary Period
Description: A period to evaluate as a condition to employment. Those who land on the practice squad, injured reserve or a reserve list usually fall into this category. A few members of the active roster are here as well.

RESERVE/ DID NOT REPORT
Rolando McClain, LB

RESERVE/ NON-FOOTBALL INJURY
Jaylon Smith, LB

RESERVE/PUP
James Hanna, TE

RESERVE/INJURED
Kellen Moore, QB
La'el Collins, LG
Ryan Davis, DE
Chaz Green, OT
Geoff Swaim, TE
Charles Tapper, DE

PRACTICE SQUAD
Clay DeBord, OT
Kadeem Edwards, G
Shaquelle Evans, WR
Rico Gathers, TE
Jeremiah George, LB
Shelby Harris, DE
Andy Jones, WR
Sammy Seamster, CB
Jameill Showers, S
Rod Smith, FB
ACTIVE ROSTER
Richard Ash, DE
Jonathan Cooper, G
 

MrB

Draft Pick
Messages
4,142
Reaction score
463
How much longer are the Cowboys stuck with Tyrone Crawford? I would not be surprised if he's a June 1st cut.
 
Messages
46,859
Reaction score
5
How much longer are the Cowboys stuck with Tyrone Crawford? I would not be surprised if he's a June 1st cut.

He supposedly had shoulder injuries this year that he tried to play through. He's another guy who we unjustly gave a huge contract to, based mostly on "potential", that he hasn't come close to living up to.

And I didn't even realize what pedestrian statistics Dez Bryant put up for the year. That doesn't happen to truly elite receivers, which he certainly isn't anymore. Which sucks for me to say because he was the last draft pick I truly got excited about, and I loved his circus like athleticisim/catches early in his career.
 
Messages
1,570
Reaction score
443
How much longer are the Cowboys stuck with Tyrone Crawford? I would not be surprised if he's a June 1st cut.
Didn't we draft him when we were still playing a 3-4 defense? Always struck me as more of a 3-4 DE. Even more reason why we shouldn't have given him that big contract.

Same with Kyle Wilbur. Drafted as a 3-4 OLB, then we switch to a 4-3. Just didn't suit the new the system.
 

NoMoRedJ

UDFA
Messages
2,477
Reaction score
56
That list of "others" in the article is a scathing indictment on this coaching staff. 13-3 might mask it for many but just looking at it is a real indictment.
 

ThoughtExperiment

Quality Starter
Messages
9,906
Reaction score
3
Didn't we draft him when we were still playing a 3-4 defense? Always struck me as more of a 3-4 DE. Even more reason why we shouldn't have given him that big contract.
It's funny to think about a few years ago when he was out for the year and Steve deemed the loss "devastating". ZeroClub even had it as his sig for a while.

Now we know Crawford is pretty much a spare. Another scapegoat and overhyped player.
 

theoneandonly

Quality Starter
Messages
5,274
Reaction score
561
There is not a guy on the needs improvement list they couldnt live without, Dez included. All too often the Patrick Petersons of the world completely erase him. He feasts off stiffs like the FA GB ran out there last week. He is like a bully, if he cant physically dominate you, he completely disapears. He is as good as he will ever be, and I'd argue on the decline.
 

cmd34

Pro Bowler
Messages
11,877
Reaction score
119
Didn't we draft him when we were still playing a 3-4 defense? Always struck me as more of a 3-4 DE. Even more reason why we shouldn't have given him that big contract.

Same with Kyle Wilbur. Drafted as a 3-4 OLB, then we switch to a 4-3. Just didn't suit the new the system.

We were in a 3-4 at the time and Crawford was a 4-3 DE at Boise State. He bulked up to play the 5 Tech only to have us change schemes a year later. Then they liked him at 3 Tech and he showed some flashes, so Jerry threw a ton of money at him. He's solid, has some position flex, but is not worth the contract they gave him.

Wilber is a tweener that this staff loves despite him not actually doing much on the field. He was on the field on those last few critical drives against Green Bay, which blows my mind.
 
Messages
46,859
Reaction score
5
I always forget Kyle Wilbur is still on the team because he literally never makes any plays.
 
Messages
1,570
Reaction score
443
That 2012 draft again;

1. Morris Claiborne CB
3. Tyrone Crawford DE
4. Kyle Wilber LB
4. Matt Johnson S
5. Danny Coale WR
6. James Hanna TE
7. Caleb McSurdy LB

That went well. Thankfully they've got better at drafting.
 

cmd34

Pro Bowler
Messages
11,877
Reaction score
119
That 2012 draft again;

1. Morris Claiborne CB
3. Tyrone Crawford DE
4. Kyle Wilber LB
4. Matt Johnson S
5. Danny Coale WR
6. James Hanna TE
7. Caleb McSurdy LB

That went well. Thankfully they've got better at drafting.

I remember that draft. I stopped watching after the Danny Coale pick and went on a 3-hour bike ride. Theebs got upset with me.
 
Messages
2,278
Reaction score
53
That list of "others" in the article is a scathing indictment on this coaching staff. 13-3 might mask it for many but just looking at it is a real indictment.


It is an indictment of the management (ahem... Jerry) for sticking with losers, JAGs and bums like Carr and Claiborne for far too damn long.This is enabled by idiots such as those at the Shithouse who claim every year that Carr and Claiborne "played great, we should extend them" despite not even finishing within the top 90 or so DBs in any meaningful stat.
 
Messages
1,570
Reaction score
443
I remember that draft. I stopped watching after the Danny Coale pick and went on a 3-hour bike ride. Theebs got upset with me.
Well at least they weren't the only ones to screw up. RGIII at pick 2, Trent Richardson at 3, Justin Blackmon at 5, Mark Barron at 7 just a few examples. Not a very impressive draft class overall - the best being Luke Kuechly, Fletcher Cox, Bobby Wagner and of course Russell Wilson.

Is it true that Jerry said they would have taken Wagner with the 2nd round pick they gave the Rams, or is that just Jerry being a media whore?
 

theoneandonly

Quality Starter
Messages
5,274
Reaction score
561
This is enabled by idiots such as those at the Shithouse who claim every year that Carr and Claiborne "played great, we should extend them"

And by playing great you mean the 15 yard cushion got reduced to a 10 yard cushion.
 

theoneandonly

Quality Starter
Messages
5,274
Reaction score
561
Bobby Wagner

Speaking of which, the defense might be slighlty better with Brockers and Wagner instead of "the man of glass". Of course that got blamed on Rob Ryan and Jerry wanting to make somebody uncomfortable. Dont get me wrong I wouldnt ask Rob to coach the local JV team, but I doubt Claiborne was his call all by himself.
 

cmd34

Pro Bowler
Messages
11,877
Reaction score
119
Is it true that Jerry said they would have taken Wagner with the 2nd round pick they gave the Rams, or is that just Jerry being a media whore?

Stephen told the season ticket holders ( I guess they do some kind of call for them after the draft each year) that had they held onto their picks, they would have selected Brockers and Wagner.
Two years later, we traded 2 picks for Demarcus Lawrence. Stephen said we would have taken Kony Ealy and Trai Turner.

Sigh.
 
Top Bottom