Cowlishaw - Packers' Rodgers No. 1 on my list even before he wins SB

[dbair1967]

He's the greatest coach in NFL history, IMO.

He's created a dynasty in a parity driven league, with only one clear cut Hall of Famer.

Eh. I dont agree. What he did in 2001 vs a vastly superior Rams team was amazing. But after cheat-gate I dont see him the same anymore. I dont think anyone will ever know all the truth about what they were doing. What got reported and admitted to was not all of what was going on.

 

[Rock Slamdance]

If your not cheating...your not trying.

 

[dbair1967]

I know QB ratings are subjective, but damn, 3 100 percent QB ratings? Aaron Rogers is fucking good.

Guess who this is:

112.1, 120.0, 140.7, 103.7, 144.7, 77.2*, 121.1, 68.8, 101.6, 107.5, 108.8

9 100+ ratings in 11 starts

 

[Rock Slamdance]

Guess who this is:

112.1, 120.0, 140.7, 103.7, 144.7, 77.2*, 121.1, 68.8, 101.6, 107.5, 108.8

9 100+ ratings in 11 starts

I think he was referring to three PERFECT ratings.

 

[Rock Slamdance]

which is 158.3

 

[dbair1967]

I think he was referring to three PERFECT ratings.

He doesnt have 3 perfect ratings. He had 3 starts over 100 and the last one was 55.4. Rodgers highest single game postseason rating was 136.8 (vs Atl)

 

[Rock Slamdance]

He doesnt have 3 perfect ratings. He had 3 starts over 100 and the last one was 55.4. Rodgers highest single game postseason rating was 136.8 (vs Atl)

I see, Just thought that was what the poster was referring to

 

[dbair1967]

I see, Just thought that was what the poster was referring to

I'll let it slide this time.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

I was referencing Roger's career. He's topped a 100 QB rating in 3 of his seasons. Brady hasn't even done that. Of course he has the championships, but it's all uphill for Rogers.

 

[Rock Slamdance]

I was referencing Roger's career. He's topped a 100 QB rating in 3 of his seasons. Brady hasn't even done that. Of course he has the championships, but it's all uphill for Rogers.

Cleared up

 

[Cythim]

I'm taking Manning #1 overall. He can win games with absolutely nothing around him.

 

[sbk92]

Eh. I dont agree. What he did in 2001 vs a vastly superior Rams team was amazing. But after cheat-gate I dont see him the same anymore. I dont think anyone will ever know all the truth about what they were doing. What got reported and admitted to was not all of what was going on.

That cheating thing is overblown, IMO.

Did he cheat? Yes. Was he the only one cheating? Highly doubtful.

I heard Jimmy Johnson on WFAN after that story broke saying that was common practice back when he coached the Cowboys. That if you weren't "cheating" you weren't trying.

Remember, prior to New England getting caught, the league sent out a memo to all 32 teams telling them to stop. I don't think you make that kind of move unless you know that behavior is pretty common. The difference is Belichick thumbed his nose to the memo.