sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
SportsDayDFW sports


Todd Archer, Cowboys beat writer for SportsDayDFW.com and The Dallas Morning News, answered readers' questions in a chat Friday. Some excerpts:

On why Dez Bryant isn't a starter:

He played in roughly 75 percent of the snaps last week. I've said it time and time again when it relates to the running backs: starting doesn't matter. It just doesn't. He's playing enough, and he doesn't know everything to be a starter yet. This isn't hating on a guy. He's excellent. Maybe the top ROY candidate, but in the game he has to be told where to line up way too many times.

On if Jason Garrett could be a better head coach than offensive coordinator and who would replace him to run the offense:

It's a question Jerry Jones wants to find out. I get the sense he will be different as a head coach than he was as the coordinator/assistant head coach. Maybe there were things he wanted to do running the offense, like benching players, changing personnel, that he didn't feel was in his purview as the assistant coach. Now he doesn't have that inhibiting him.

On if he thinks the Cowboys will quit this week:

I don't. And if guys do, they won't play next week and may not be with this team or any team. Being a quitter is the worse label a player can have.

On if Jason Garrett is more like Bill Parcells or Wade Phillips and if his hiring is just a stop-gap measure:

From listening to Jerry Jones on Monday and again on his radio show today, I get the sense he wants Jason Garrett to work out. He doesn't want to have to go through a long drawn-out process. When he hired Garrett in 2007, he thought he had a guy that could be his head coach for a long time. Now he's getting the chance, even if it is under bad circumstances.

On if the Cowboys will address the quarterback position in the draft:

Garrett was asked today if there is a time where McGee could play, like in mop up duty last week, and he basically said no. Kitna will be the guy unless there is an injury. I do think they need to look at quarterback in the draft, but not anywhere near the first few rounds. I understand there are a lot of Andrew Luck fans out there, but the Cowboys believe Romo is in the prime of his career. This team has too many needs to take a QB, IMO.

On the chances of Tony Romo playing in Week 13 or 14:

Less than 2 percent. I just don't see the wisdom in playing the guy if they have a 3-11 record. What good would it do? Now, I can see Garrett wanting him to play because he wants to win games, but Jerry Jones should not put Romo at such a risk in a lost season.

On if scrapping the 3-4 defense would help:

I'm not scrapping the 3-4. I think the defense works just fine when players do what they are supposed to do.

On if Jason Garrett has the authority to bench players:

I think Wade Phillips had that authority, too and didn't exercise it. We'll find out if Garrett is the same way. I get the sense he won't be.
 
C

Cr122

Guest
It always takes about a full season for a wide receiver to learn the offense, next year Dez will start and make the pro bowl, yeah he's that good.
 

Jon88

Pro Bowler
Messages
19,523
Reaction score
0
We'll probably put Romo back in around week 12 because we're f---ing stupid.
 

sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
It always takes about a full season for a wide receiver to learn the offense, next year Dez will start and make the pro bowl, yeah he's that good.

It doesn't take a full season to learn where to line up.

Dez is a lot of great things but intelligent isn't one of them.
 

cowboysforlife

Spectator
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
I think Dez will be a outstanding player in the long run. He has the heart and the will to win.

But I feel that part of the trouble with him, Is that Wade let the players take care of themselves and no pushed them.

I feel that you get a coach to push the players to get better you will see a big change in his playing as you will with other players.
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
57,380
Reaction score
8,077
We'll probably put Romo back in around week 12 because we're f---ing stupid.

I think it depends entirely on the OL. If they play the way they did today for the rest of the yr, there's no reason Romo shouldnt play.
 

sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
I think it depends entirely on the OL. If they play the way they did today for the rest of the yr, there's no reason Romo shouldnt play.

There's no reason he should play.

If you can't contend for a playoff berth, bringing back your franchise QB for a couple of whogivesashat games at the end of the year is pointless. Use those games to evaluate players you don't know.
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
57,380
Reaction score
8,077
There's no reason he should play.

If you can't contend for a playoff berth, bringing back your franchise QB for a couple of whogivesashat games at the end of the year is pointless. Use those games to evaluate players you don't know.

If he's healthy, he should play unless they feel the OL cant protect him.

Romo IS the future, not the backups.
 

sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
If he's healthy, he should play unless they feel the OL cant protect him.

Romo IS the future, not the backups.

Negative. You gain nothing playing Romo. You already know him. He's already developed. There's nothing to gain. It's a completely pointless move to make when you're already out of the playoffs.

But putting a guy like McGee in actually serves a purpose. You can find out a lot about a player you don't know yet. It helps you on decision making in the offseason as well as develops a younger player.
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
57,380
Reaction score
8,077
Negative. You gain nothing playing Romo. You already know him. He's already developed. There's nothing to gain. It's a completely pointless move to make when you're already out of the playoffs.

But putting a guy like McGee in actually serves a purpose. You can find out a lot about a player you don't know yet. It helps you on decision making in the offseason as well as develops a younger player.

I guess we'd have to agree to disagree, and I suspect Garrett will disagree as well. I doubt many (if any) teams in simialr situations would do the same.

The ONLY reasons to avoid playing Romo are 1) if he isnt physically able, or reinjury is very likely or 2) they feel the OL cant protect him

Otherwise, he plays. As he should.
 

Plymkr

2
Messages
2,126
Reaction score
0
I guess I missed it, but, I haven't seen or didn't see Bryant being told where to lineup in the last two games. And, I don't care. Just get him the damn ball and he will make a play.
 

Bob Sacamano

All-Pro
Messages
26,436
Reaction score
3
I guess I missed it, but, I haven't seen or didn't see Bryant being told where to lineup in the last two games. And, I don't care. Just get him the damn ball and he will make a play.

Apparently they don't ask him to run that many routes. But whatever works because Bryant is tearing shit up.
 

Jon88

Pro Bowler
Messages
19,523
Reaction score
0
Apparently they don't ask him to run that many routes. But whatever works because Bryant is tearing shit up.

He's the closest thing to Moss that I've seen.

He doesn't have that same gazelle make-up, but he he plays his ass off and is very athletic.
 
Last edited:

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
57,380
Reaction score
8,077
He's the closest thing to Moss that I've seen.

He doesn't have that same gazelle make-up, but he he plays his ass off and is very athletic.

His desire and work ethic are vastly superior to Moss'. He also isnt a one or two route guy and will go over the middle.
 

Jon88

Pro Bowler
Messages
19,523
Reaction score
0
His desire and work ethic are vastly superior to Moss'. He also isnt a one or two route guy and will go over the middle.

That's right. If Moss had that same desire and work ethic his entire career he would have blown Rice out of the water.
 

Plymkr

2
Messages
2,126
Reaction score
0
But Moss doesn't and never did. Moss has the "throw it up and I get it" route. That is it. It works for him.

Dez is going to be beyond Moss as a COMPLETE player, with hopefully helping Dallas get some rings in the process.

Dez is the real deal.
 

sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
His desire and work ethic are vastly superior to Moss'. He also isnt a one or two route guy and will go over the middle.

Jesus Christ, you're a homer.

Take it from the guy that was right, not wrong, about this season. Randy Moss is, was and always will be a superior talent than Dez Bryant.

The most dominant receiver in the history of the league. He walked through a first ballot hall of fame career.
 
Top Bottom