2012 Todd McShay Invitational Chatter Thread

Cr122 · Feb 17, 2012

Ah, there's still two rounds to go. No clear winner yet.

BangersandMash · Feb 17, 2012

Todd McShay said:
Redskins get 106th rated player in the 63rd spot. Reach or good selection?

I wanted Weeden but the Saints inexplicably took him. In my eyes Foles or Osweiller are the next best options due to their upside. Cousins IMO is another John Beck/Drew Stanton/Trent Edwards, etc.

I could have stayed at 39 and taken Weeden but that would have been a reach too. I'd rather reach for a QB with upside and pick up an extra third round pick. Now I have 4 picks in the next 2 rounds to continue to replenish the roster.

Todd McShay · Feb 17, 2012

New York's pick is in.

Round 2 complete.

Kick off Round 3 is the Colts (Sheik).

30 minute selection times now...

Has until 4:49 est to make a pick.

Sheik · Feb 17, 2012

Reuben Randle. WR. LSU.

A player that will be gone by the middle of the second round in April.

Deuce511 · Feb 17, 2012

Sheik said:
I wanted to do that to never_catch yesterday.

On a side note, he could easily win again this year.

I'm definitely happy with mine so far, but haters gonna hate when it comes to grading.

Sheik · Feb 17, 2012

never_catch22 said:
I'm definitely happy with mine so far, but haters gonna hate when it comes to grading.

Were you NE last year?

Todd McShay · Feb 17, 2012

Colts kicked off the third.

Rams (Doomsdaydefense) are on the clock and have until 4:54 to make a selection.

Cythim · Feb 17, 2012

Sheik said:
Reuben Randle. WR. LSU.

A player that will be gone by the middle of the second round in April.

Damn you, I was getting ready to look for a trade to get him!

DoomsdayDefense · Feb 17, 2012

Hold on I need to get caught on up what I missed and who is available. Selection forthcoming.

SixisBetter · Feb 17, 2012

never_catch22 said:
I'm definitely happy with mine so far, but haters gonna hate when it comes to grading.

Right,I feel the same way.

All 4 of my picks(as Giants GM last year)made the teams they were drafted by,with two playing in 16 gms as rooks,and one playing in 12 gms.The 4th was injured,but played some when he came back.
My draft was graded as "C",or average.
Not complaining,it is what it is.
But the grading system is subjective.

Todd McShay · Feb 17, 2012

SixisBetter said:
Right,I feel the same way.

All 4 of my picks(as Giants GM last year)made the teams they were drafted by,with two playing in 16 gms as rooks,and one playing in 12 gms.The 4th was injured,but played some when he came back.
My draft was graded as "C",or average.
Not complaining,it is what it is.
But the grading system is subjective.

That was last year. In the Kiper.

The grading in the McShay is exceptional.

Todd McShay · Feb 17, 2012

The Rams selection is in.

Vikings sent me a value board. Once I decipher it, I'll post the pick. If you've got a selection coming up, get ready.

Cythim · Feb 17, 2012

Denver is looking to trade up, anyone interested?

SixisBetter · Feb 17, 2012

Todd McShay said:
That was last year. In the Kiper.

The grading in the McShay is exceptional.

You da man,no question Mr McShay.

Todd McShay · Feb 17, 2012

Vikings pick is in. Browns gave me a value board.

Next 5:
69. Bengals (via Buccaneers trade) -
70. Redskins
71. Jaguars
72. Bills
73. Bears (via Panthers on Greg Olsen trade)

Todd McShay · Feb 17, 2012

The Cincinatti Bengals are on the clock. Peplaw has until 5:23 to get a pick in.

Todd McShay · Feb 17, 2012

Bengals pick is in, via a value board that I forgot he sent in. Sorry for the delay.

Washington Redskins are on the clock. Bangersandmash has until 5:32 to make a selection.

Cythim · Feb 17, 2012

SixisBetter said:
Right,I feel the same way.

All 4 of my picks(as Giants GM last year)made the teams they were drafted by,with two playing in 16 gms as rooks,and one playing in 12 gms.The 4th was injured,but played some when he came back.
My draft was graded as "C",or average.
Not complaining,it is what it is.
But the grading system is subjective.

I had Titus Young (600yds, 6TDs, drafted 10 spots ahead of where I got him) but my other pick was Cannon and he ended up falling because of his cancer (didn't know about it during the draft). I also had Seattle in prime position to get a top QB with the #7 and #12 picks this year. never_catch22 is ruining the ground work I laid by beefing up a defense that ranked top 10 in total yards and points allowed. Taking BPA is great except when you are drafting a position where there is no need.

Sheik · Feb 17, 2012

Cythim said:
I had Titus Young (600yds, 6TDs, drafted 10 spots ahead of where I got him) but my other pick was Cannon and he ended up falling because of his cancer (didn't know about it during the draft). I also had Seattle in prime position to get a top QB with the #7 and #12 picks this year. never_catch22 is ruining the ground work I laid by beefing up a defense that ranked top 10 in total yards and points allowed. Taking BPA is great except when you are drafting a position where there is no need.

These things always look way different 2 or 3 years down the road. The winner is always up for debate once these players show what they are or aren't.

Steelcurtain · Feb 17, 2012

We are doing a 7 round mock draft over on the spawn board. There are still some teams available. Anyone is welcome to join!!!!

http://spawnboards.com/index.cgi?board=sports&action=display&thread=4870

Cr122

Guest

Practice Squad

1

All-Pro

2

All-Pro

1

2

Practice Squad

Anywhere on the line.

1

1

2

Anywhere on the line.

1

1

1

2

All-Pro

Spectator