1/9 Gosselin Chat

[superpunk]

I'm talking about the draft only. If the homers mock him for missing so badly on Carpenter, then they shouldn't praise the Cowboys for taking guys on this "moron's" Top 50 list.

Oh, it seemed like the body of your comments in this thread indicated that if you agree with Gosselin or think he's valuable for one thing then you can't criticize him for anything or you're a hypocrite homer.

 

[bbgun]

Oh, it seemed like the body of your comments in this thread indicated that if you agree with Gosselin or think he's valuable for one thing then you can't criticize him for anything or you're a hypocrite homer.

Not at all. I noted that his predictions don't always hit paydirt, but the homers have a way of accentuating his misses more than his hits.

 

[ThreeSportStar80]

I agree with a few of his comments, but not many...

 

[Theebs]

My understanding is/was that his top 100 list was a general consensus on where guys from around the league had people ranked, and not his own personal opinion/breakdown.

No?

yes it is.

and he has the most accurate mock draft every year because of it.

 

[dbair1967]

I love the Homers when they say he is the end-all expert on draft picks and his sources are the best...but when he tells you that Jerry ran off Jimmy, he's just crazy.

He should stick to what he knows about, the draft

Because he is utterly clueless about everything else.

 

[dbair1967]

My understanding is/was that his top 100 list was a general consensus on where guys from around the league had people ranked, and not his own personal opinion/breakdown.

No?

Thats correct, he doesnt really have any true opinions. He bases all his draft stuff on his team sources throughout the leagfue. Its why he constantly cranks out the most accurate top-100 list year in and year out.