sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
Andrew Luck leading the way in 2012

By Steve Muench
Scouts Inc.

It's never too early to look ahead to next year, so here's a rundown of three potential 2012 NFL draft prospects from each offensive position group to watch when the 2011 college season kicks off.


Quarterbacks

Andrew Luck*, Stanford
Luck has everything NFL teams covet in franchise quarterbacks, including football acumen, accuracy, arm strength, mobility and size. He is the consensus favorite to be the first overall pick if he declares for the 2012 draft.

Terrelle Pryor, Ohio State
The NCAA suspended five Ohio State players, including Pryor, for the first five games of the 2011 season, and it will be interesting to see how much the time off affects him. While he struggled against Miami, Wisconsin and Iowa last year, he had his best overall season. Overall, he has the raw tools that made Cam Newton and Jake Locker early picks this year despite their respective flaws.

Nick Foles, Arizona
Foles made strides in his second season as the Wildcats' starter last year, and he has the tools to develop into an effective starter in the NFL. However, he plays in a spread scheme that simplifies reads and he tends to lock on to his primary target.

Matt Barkley*, USC
Barkley is a field general with the tools and intangibles to be the No. 2 quarterback on this list, but he could return to USC for his senior season in 2012 and put himself in the running to go first overall in 2013.


Running backs

Trent Richardson*, Alabama
Richardson isn't as instinctive as 2011 first-round pick and former running mate Mark Ingram, but he has more natural ability. He is a big back with the power to produce between the tackles and speed to break long runs.

Dan "Boom" Herron, Ohio State
Herron is another one of the Ohio State players the NCAA suspended for the first five games of the 2011 season, and he too will have to make up for lost time when he gets on the field. Although he doesn't have elite size, he is a hard-nosed inside runner with enough burst to get outside.

Knile Davis*, Arkansas
At 220 pounds, Davis has the balance to run through would-be arm tackles, above-average lateral mobility for his size and the speed to rip off a long run when he gets a seam. Now that QB Ryan Mallett has moved on to the NFL, Davis will have to show scouts he can produce when he is the focal point.


Wide receivers

Justin Blackmon*, Oklahoma State
Blackmon made some talented corners look pedestrian in 2011, and there's no doubt he can stretch the field at the NFL level. He also shows great competitiveness both after the catch and when the ball is in the air. If he stays healthy and declares, he's the odds-on favorite to be the first receiver taken in the 2012 draft.

Michael Floyd, Notre Dame
Floyd is currently suspended, and although he is expected to return to the team, he's had three brushes with the law because of alcohol-related issues. However, he has the frame and ball skills to develop into a productive possession receiver and red zone threat at the next level.

Ryan Broyles, Oklahoma
Broyles doesn't have elite size, but he has the burst to separate from underneath man coverage and produce after the catch. He can also return punts.


Tight ends

Michael Egnew, Missouri
Egnew is coming off a breakout season, and he'll have to prove he wasn't just a flash in the pan in 2010. He doesn't offer much as an in-line blocker but he has the frame (6-foot-6, 240 pounds) to produce in the red zone and enough speed to make plays down the seam.

Orson Charles*, Georgia
Charles is another receiving tight end prospect who doesn't project as a strong in-line blocker but has the foot speed to get off the line and the burst to get behind linebackers off play-action.

George Bryan, NC State
Bryan isn't much of a big-play threat; however, he has the size (6-5, 265 pounds) and toughness to develop into an effective in-line blocker and reliable short-to-intermediate receiver.


Offensive linemen

Matt Kalil*, USC
The reason Tyron Smith, the No. 9 overall player drafted in 2011, lined up on the right side for the Trojans is Kalil has locked down the left side the past two seasons and has what it takes to do the same at the next level. There's also a lot to like about the bloodlines here. Carolina took older brother OC Ryan Kalil in the second round of the 2007 draft, and Buffalo drafted their father, Frank, in the 11th round of the 1982 draft.

Mike Brewster, Ohio State
Brewster enters his fourth season as the team's starting center, and there's a lot to like about his awareness. He also has good size (6-5, 305 pounds) and tenacity, which teams look for in their interior offensive linemen.

Riley Reiff*, Iowa
Reiff is a versatile offensive lineman with starting experience at guard and both offensive tackle spots over the past two seasons. He has the length at 6-6 to play tackle in the NFL but he might be a better fit on the right than he is on the left side.
 

cmd34

Pro Bowler
Messages
11,877
Reaction score
119
Would have been super high on Richardson had we not drafted Murray.

I really like Michael Brewster. Riley Reiff reminds me of Doug Free.

I have no idea why Terrelle Pryor is on that list.
 

sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
Would have been super high on Richardson had we not drafted Murray.

I really like Michael Brewster. Riley Reiff reminds me of Doug Free.

I have no idea why Terrelle Pryor is on that list.

Isn't Felix a free agent after this year?
 

cmd34

Pro Bowler
Messages
11,877
Reaction score
119
Isn't Felix a free agent after this year?
He's under contract for 2 more years. Then, he'll have 5 years of service, so it depends on how the new CBA determines Unrestricted Free Agency.
 
Last edited:

sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
Galloway says we were real high on Ingram. Had we taken the Jags trade, we might have been able to land him in a trade back into the first round. I know the Saints gave up next year's 1st in their move, but that doesn't mean the Cowboys would have had to. They might have gotten a deal done with another team.

Had Ingram came to Dallas the Emmitt Smith comparisons would be off the charts.

And I'm not convinced Tyron Smith would have definitely been off the board by pick 16.

I think I would have taken that deal.
 

cmd34

Pro Bowler
Messages
11,877
Reaction score
119
Galloway says we were real high on Ingram. Had we taken the Jags trade, we might have been able to land him in a trade back into the first round. I know the Saints gave up next year's 1st in their move, but that doesn't mean the Cowboys would have had to. They might have gotten a deal done with another team.

Had Ingram came to Dallas the Emmitt Smith comparisons would be off the charts.

And I'm not convinced Tyron Smith would have definitely been off the board by pick 16.

I think I would have taken that deal.

I think we all know how I feel about Tyron Smith... and I would have taken that deal too.
 

sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
I'm torn on that. On one hand, it's nice to not get cute and take the super blue chipper.

On the other hand, I recognize the value in that deal and the potential that brings.

Tough decision.
 
Messages
10,636
Reaction score
0
See I think Broyles has more playmaking then the Giants Steve Smith.

I respect NYG Steve Smith, but he will never scare me the way Car Steve Smith did
 
Messages
46,859
Reaction score
5
If we took a runningback, and ignored our line, I would've been pissed.

Give me a blue chip OT over a blue chip runningback any day of the week.
 

LAZARUS_LOGAN

Pro Bowler
Messages
14,639
Reaction score
207
Galloway says we were real high on Ingram. Had we taken the Jags trade, we might have been able to land him in a trade back into the first round. I know the Saints gave up next year's 1st in their move, but that doesn't mean the Cowboys would have had to. They might have gotten a deal done with another team.

Had Ingram came to Dallas the Emmitt Smith comparisons would be off the charts.

And I'm not convinced Tyron Smith would have definitely been off the board by pick 16.

I think I would have taken that deal.



If the Cowboys had taken the deal with the Jags, more than likely Smith would not made it to #16. You would have had Fairly, Quinn, and Smith on board still. ALL THREE WOULD BE GONE before pick #16. Now more than likely the Redskins would have taken one of those three. I don't like the idea of facing either Fairly or Quinn twice a year---particularly Quinn with nothing on on the other side to counteract. Then again, I can see the Redskins taking Smith in because he would be a need---Trent Williams and Smith would be a hell of a bookend OT tandem, and also for no other reason but to f.uck with the Cowboys. If that would have been the scenario, Fairly would still fall to the Lions and Quinn would still fall to the Rams.

Bottomline is, either the Vikings or the Lions would snag up Smith if Fairly (Redskins) was gone in another scenario, and even with the extra pick, no guarantee we would have been able to trade back into the 1st and get Ingram, and then imagine the bitchfest on these boards after losing out on Smith and not getting Ingram. So, Jerry as it would appear was being strategic in standing pat. He did the right thing: got his man Smith and kept two players in Quinn and Fairly out of the NFC East. I think that is worth not taking the extra pick in a trade down.
 
Last edited:

LAZARUS_LOGAN

Pro Bowler
Messages
14,639
Reaction score
207
If we took a runningback, and ignored our line, I would've been pissed.

Give me a blue chip OT over a blue chip runningback any day of the week.


Amen. The game has changed and RBs are a dime a dozen in this NFL.
 

sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
If the Cowboys had taken the deal with the Jags, more than likely Smith would not made it to #16. You would have had Fairly, Quinn, and Smith on board still. ALL THREE WOULD BE GONE before pick #16. Now more than likely the Redskins would have taken one of those three. I don't like the idea of facing either Fairly or Quinn twice a year---particularly Quinn with nothing on on the other side to counteract. Then again, I can see the Redskins taking Smith in because he would be a need---Trent Williams and Smith would be a hell of a bookend OT tandem, and also for no other reason but to f.uck with the Cowboys. If that would have been the scenario, Fairly would still fall to the Lions and Quinn would still fall to the Rams.

Bottomline is, either the Vikings or the Lions would snag up Smith if Fairly (Redskins) was gone in another scenario, and even with the extra pick, no guarantee we would have been able to trade back into the 1st and get Ingram, and then imagine the bitchfest on these boards after losing out on Smith and not getting Ingram. So, Jerry as it would appear was being strategic in standing pat. He did the right thing: got his man Smith and kept two players in Quinn and Fairly out of the NFC East. I think that is worth not taking the extra pick in a trade down.

You're providing me with your own predictions of how the picks would play out under a different scenario and expecting me to take it as fact.

I wouldn't ever make draft decisions to block a rival. That's idiotic nonsense.
 
Top Bottom