cmd34

Pro Bowler
Messages
11,877
Reaction score
119
IMO, this next off-season will be the deciding factor on whether this core group of players gets a legitimate shot at a championship. Small fixes won't do it. A new Tight Ends coach or a new Quality Control guy who the players all really respect isn't going to change the key problem, the total lack of accountability.


1) Jerry has to remove himself from the equation. I know, I know. He never will, it’s his team, etc. If he isn’t capable or willing, nothing else matters. It is more evident every day that Jimmy, not Jerry, was solely responsible for being the architect of those championship teams (the last Superbowl was won with a roster where 80% of the players were drafted , signed, or traded for by Jimmy Johnson). The team doesn’t fear or truly respect Jerry’s “puppet” coaches. He can continue to market the team, the stadium, chair committees, etc. but he needs to relieve himself of any personnel decisions. Every other General Manager with the exception of Mike Brown, is able to focus on the roster. Even Mike Brown doesn’t involve himself in all of the other activities Jerry does.

2) Hire an outside GM and or Head Coach. Someone with little or no ties to the organizition (translation: no loyalty or obligation to Jerry). It can be a big name HC who handpicks his GM (think Pete Carroll in Seattle) or an up and coming GM and allow him to pick his Head Coach. The entire scouting and coaching staff needs to be let go. There should be zero pressure from Jerry to retain anyone. If you want true accountability you have to allow the architect to bring in his people.

3) Fix the offensive line. This is another reason the scouting department needs to be dumped. Whoever is evaluating the Offensive Line has been a disaster. Tomorrow, I’ll post a thread detailing how we can feasibly dump this offensive line but it really won’t matter if the same yahoo is evaluating and signing off on the replacements. We need 3 to 4 new starters on the Offensive Line. That may seem drastic but the change is absolutely necessary. We have to be better at establishing some sort of running game and we must improve at pass blocking. Bill Callahan can’t turn the likes of Bernadeau, Livings, Cook, into anything more than they are.

4) Find a safety. We have the corners and we have a couple of pass rushers (Ware and Ratliff). Now we need a cerebral, athletic captain back there to capitalize on opponents mistakes. How many times do you see a Romo pass deflected and there is a DB to make the interception? Now look at us. If a ball is deflected or broken up by a CB the ball falls harmlessly to the ground. If a QB overthrows a WR the ball will hit wide open turf. Last night when Brandon Marshall beat Claiborne for the TD, both safeties were standing right by each other, about 15 yards shallow of the reception. Danny McCray now has more career starts for the Dallas Cowboys (2) than he did in 4 years at LSU(0). We can’t keep playing any guy back there. Turnover margin is almost always an indication of a winning team.

There are other needs but these 4 MUST happen. The alternative is a flashy team that occasionally flashes brilliance but shrinks when it counts. The alternative is a brilliant draft pick (Sean Lee) surrounded by draft day blunders (2009 draft). The alternative is 1 playoff win in 16 years. The alternative is one of the most popular and successful franchises in all of sports being completely mediocre.
 
Messages
46,859
Reaction score
5
#1 and #2 just aren't going to happen. Not even worth discussing.

I wholeheartedly agree with #3.

Outside of Tyron - and really, you should nail a top 10 selection - we've whiffed time and time again in evaluating offensive lineman.

Here's a look at all the offensive lineman we've drafted since 2003 (picked Parcells era and north since a lot of improvements to scouting department took place then:

2003:
Al Johnson, C, 2nd round
Justin Bates, G, 7th round

2004:
Jacob Rogers, T, 2nd round
Stephen Peterman, G, 3rd round

2005:
Rob Petitti, T, 6th round

2006:
Pat McQuistain, T, 7th round

2007:
James Marten, T, 3rd round
Doug Free, T, 4th round

2008:
NONE

2009:
Robert Brewster, G, 3rd round

2010:
Sam Young, T, 7th round

2011:
Tyron Smith, T, 1st round
David Arkin, G, 4th round
Bill Nagy, C, 7th round

2012:
NONE


Ten drafts, 13 draft picks - 25% of which 6th rounders or lower ...

This teams priorities are fucked.
 
Messages
2,064
Reaction score
0
We've selected more TE's in the first two rounds of the draft over the last 8 years than we have OL despite there being 5 OL starting positions.
 

Sheik

All-Pro
Messages
24,809
Reaction score
5
There is no hope for this core group.

Its time we come to grips with it.

if joe fan can watch this team and identify the holes, but the guy in charge can't, you have a huge issues within the organization. The offensive line won't get better by throwing bad players in there from other teams. There aren't any young lineman on the team with potential.

The safety positions have been awful since Roy took a nosedive.

we just have to wait. Wait for the bastard dies and hope his son sells the team.
 

cmd34

Pro Bowler
Messages
11,877
Reaction score
119
You think this is bad, wait til Jerry's partially retarded grandson takes over.

I should be battling Jerry in Hell before that day comes.

If I believed in that sort of thing.
 

Theebs

Quality Starter
Messages
8,534
Reaction score
0
I should be battling Jerry in Hell before that day comes.

If I believed in that sort of thing.

Hey he is already learning from the best.

The guy who cleaned Jerry's glasses against the giants is his dad.
 
Messages
3,665
Reaction score
22
IMO, this next off-season will be the deciding factor on whether this core group of players gets a legitimate shot at a championship. Small fixes won't do it.

I don't want to be an ass here, but I think you are being overly optimistic. I don't see how they can build a championship OL, coaching staff, front office, etc. in the next 3 or 4 years. Jerry is not only still in denial, he's still in charge.

It is best to think of Romo as a tragic hero. He's living a Greek tragedy. That's his destiny. It sucks, but sometimes life isn't fair.

Ware and Witten will finish without championships too, but they won't get blamed for it. Romo will.
 

cmd34

Pro Bowler
Messages
11,877
Reaction score
119
I don't want to be an ass here, but I think you are being overly optimistic. I don't see how they can build a championship OL, coaching staff, front office, etc. in the next 3 or 4 years. Jerry is not only still in denial, he's still in charge.

It is best to think of Romo as a tragic hero. He's living a Greek tragedy. That's his destiny. It sucks, but sometimes life isn't fair.

Ware and Witten will finish without championships too, but they won't get blamed for it. Romo will.

I feel the #1 problem is Jerry. He likes the attention, the money, the buzz so he allows an existence where Romo can have 5 INT games and MVP caliber games within weeks of each other. Dez is worth the trouble because he's just so damn talented. Felix Jones was really good at Arkansas so we have to find a way to use him. Garrett has no true power and is useless as a playcaller.

So without fixing that (Jerry the GM) nothing else matters. He has to do like Steinbrenner finally did and concede defeat, hire qualified people, and watch what happens. No one thought Steinbrenner was ever capable of not being in charge. A Brian Cashman and a Joe Torre later, the Yankees have had 5 championships and 7 WS appearances.

I think once Jerry is removed (by choice or by death) the lack of accountability starts to go away. Hiring a strong HC starts that process sooner.
 

Theebs

Quality Starter
Messages
8,534
Reaction score
0
Just look at what is happening in Oakland.

It's obvious to everyone except the family that thinks its a good idea daddy does some rappin on tv commercials to help sell more shitty food no one wants to eat.

That damn family will never fix the problem because it's them and why the hell would they throw away the amount of wealth they are accumulating.

They have three trophies, what the hell do they care.
 
Messages
3,665
Reaction score
22
I feel the #1 problem is Jerry. He likes the attention, the money, the buzz so he allows an existence where Romo can have 5 INT games and MVP caliber games within weeks of each other. Dez is worth the trouble because he's just so damn talented. Felix Jones was really good at Arkansas so we have to find a way to use him. Garrett has no true power and is useless as a playcaller.

So without fixing that (Jerry the GM) nothing else matters. He has to do like Steinbrenner finally did and concede defeat, hire qualified people, and watch what happens. No one thought Steinbrenner was ever capable of not being in charge. A Brian Cashman and a Joe Torre later, the Yankees have had 5 championships and 7 WS appearances.

I think once Jerry is removed (by choice or by death) the lack of accountability starts to go away. Hiring a strong HC starts that process sooner.

I don't disagree with a word of that. I just don't think it will be fixed quickly enough for Romo, Witten, and Ware.
 

yimyammer

Pro Bowler
Messages
10,558
Reaction score
4,438
It is more evident every day that Jimmy, not Jerry, was solely responsible for being the architect of those championship teams

I'm as big of a fan of Jimmy as the next guy but he wasn't solely responsible for building that team. What we had was an amazing confluence of events that came together to create one of the most magical times in Cowboy history. Including but not limited to the trade of the century, many doses of luck & many individuals (even carry overs from the Landry regime, believe it or not) who helped build that team.

Those times were wonderful but they also jaded me making it more difficult to accept the reality of the league as it presently exists. I.e. parity creates teams that are close in talent which leads to close games which leads to maddening/exciting finishes.

Jerry drives me nuts and he always will but we're stuck with him and I think given these circumstances, were better off with Garrett provided he doesn't have a stubborn streak that prevents him from making changes within himself that need to be made in order to succeed. That may ultimately include but not be limited to hiring an OC, I don't know, I'm just spit-balling here.

I may be dead wrong but unless the team completely revolts against him, I still believe we should just ride Garrett out for another 5+ years because I can't help but believe he's smart enough to figure it out and eventually assemble a team that takes us once again back to the promise land. I'm not saying he's the best man for the job, I'm not qualified to say, I'm merely suggesting he may be the best man for this job. Plus, I'm really dubious over whether changing the coaching staff every 3-4 years is ever going to get them anywhere.

Hope can make one delusional and perhaps that's what I am, but I am still holding out hope that while Jerry may be publicly spouting off about being Super Bowl caliber, they are privately acknowledging they're in year two of a rebuilding process and part of that process is getting the Oline improved. I hope we see evidence of that improvement as the year progresses with a substantial jump next year. I also fully admit its looking pretty awful right now. I'm certainly no expert but I have noticed the offense is getting to the line much faster giving Romo time to read the defense and as bad as last night was, there were only two penalties.

Additionally there were a ton of plays left on the field that could have changed the outcome of that game dramatically (Romo overthrow of Dez that looked like a gimme TD, Dez's bad adjustment that lead to the pick 6, Otree's missed catch that lead to the pick, these alone could have swung the score at least 17 points in our favor).

I think Jerry does his team and himself a disservice by constantly trying to pump up his team as Super Bowl caliber. He insults the intelligence of the fans who understand you can't win it every year and who would appreciate seeing a team with a plan and measurable steps accomplished toward completing that plan. I know I really enjoyed the 1-15 and 7-9 seasons after Jimmy took over because you could see marked improvement from year to year (and game to game for the most part). I think fans are far more patient than he gives them credit for when they have confidence in the people in charge.

I'm a little surprised I'm typing this after last night, but I didn't really feel like the team quit (well, maybe in the last 6-7 minutes). I saw a game where every bounce went against them (Ex: the well defending ball that landed right into the hands of the tight end that was lying on the turf on his back) that snowballed and ultimately lead to a blow out. They were behind and Romo had to press the issue and go pass happy plus the D was missing several players as well.

I'm dreaming that Garrett's process starts to show itself as the season comes to a close and I hope for the first time in a long time we have a team playing their best as the season comes to a close.

Like I said, Hope can make one delusional and perhaps that's what I am but I can't help myself, its the fan in me.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom