sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
RAINER SABIN / The Dallas Morning News


Need meter: Eight out of 10 stars (offensive line), three out of 10 stars (tight ends).

On the roster: Guard Travis Bright, Guard Phil Costa, Guard Leonard Davis , Guard Montrae Holland, Guard Kyle Kosier, Tackle Alex Barron , Tackle Robert Brewster, Tackle Marc Colombo , Tackle Doug Free , Tackle Jermey Parnell, Tackle Sam Young, Center Andre Gurode, Tight end Martellus Bennett , Tight end John Phillips , Tight end Martin Rucker, Tight end Jason Witten.

From the outset of the season, the offensive line proved deficient.

In the Cowboys’ season-opening loss to Washington, right tackle Alex Barron was assessed three holding penalties — the last of which negated a touchdown that could have won the game on the final play. Barron was soon relegated to the bench, and Marc Colombo reassumed his starting position.

But Colombo, who had knee surgery in the summer, didn’t fare much better. In 2010, pass rushers targeted him and he allowed seven sacks — the most on the team. But as much as Colombo’s performance was disappointing, the steady play of left tackle Doug Free was pleasantly surprising.

After veteran Flozell Adams was released, Free stepped into the line’s most important position and thrived. Although he committed the most penalties — 11 — Free allowed only five sacks. Along with the Pro Bowl season Andre Gurode had and the improved blocking of right guard Leonard Davis, who yielded no sacks and was flagged for one penalty in the last six games, Free’s emergence was encouraging.

Depth, however, remains a major concern along the line. Eight linemen played for the Cowboys last season, but the reserves were rarely deployed. Phil Costa and Montrae Holland were on the field for 286 snaps. Promising rookie tackle Sam Young, meanwhile, never saw action on offense.

At tight end, the Cowboys appear to be set. Jason Witten authored another Pro Bowl season, catching 94 passes for 1,002 yards and nine touchdowns while burnishing his credentials for the Hall of Fame. He led the team in receptions and receiving touchdowns.

Although Martellus Bennett didn’t make the offensive impact Witten did, he proved serviceable as a blocking tight end and didn’t surrender a sack. But Bennett’s role could be reduced next year with the return of John Phillips, who tore his ACL in a preseason game last year.

What the Cowboys should do: The Cowboys need to improve the offensive line, either by acquiring a player through free agency or the draft. Colombo’s best days appear to be behind him, and the Cowboys need to reinforce that position. Keeping Free, who could become a restricted free agent, is also a priority.

Interesting fact: Since 1967, the Cowboys have drafted two offensive linemen in the first round.

Who’s available

Tyson Clabo Atlanta...........Tackle made his first Pro Bowl in 2010
Willie Colon Pittsburgh.........Tackle missed 2010 after tearing Achilles tendon
Matt Light N. England..........Tackle protects Tom Brady’s blind side
Tyron Smith USC..................Last USC tackle Cowboys drafted? Jacob Rogers
Nate Solder Colorado...........Consensus All-American, but worth the ninth pick?
 
C

Cr122

Guest
I don't want to take an offensive linemen with the 9th pick.

I'd rather trade the 9th pick if no one was there on defense we liked, then we could pick up an extra pick to get the offensive line help in the second or third rounds.

There are some good guards in this draft that we could pick up later.
 

dbair1967

Administrator
Messages
57,614
Reaction score
8,289
Matt Light was a turnstile this yr, and he's old. I dont want anything to do with him.
 

LAZARUS_LOGAN

Pro Bowler
Messages
14,639
Reaction score
207
I don't want to take an offensive linemen with the 9th pick.

I'd rather trade the 9th pick if no one was there on defense we liked, then we could pick up an extra pick to get the offensive line help in the second or third rounds.

There are some good guards in this draft that we could pick up later.


I agree.
 

Mr.Po

2
Messages
2,711
Reaction score
0
There is more to tweek than one player but getting rid of Dumbo is an immediate quick fix in the right direction. A lamp post is a better option. Draft or FA?

Here is a list of O-line FA. Franchise tags will obviously take some of these names out of the equation.

2011 NFL Free Agent Offensive Linemen

Tyson Clabo (ATL) – Clabo has formed one half of Atlanta’s dominant run-blocking right side. He’s a nasty, physical run blocking tackle who has developed into a steady pass blocker as well. Though the Falcons have several key components of their offensive line set to hit free agency this offseason, none will be more important than ensuring that Ryan stays upright than Clabo. Entering the league as an undrafted free agent, Clabo will be set to strike a lucrative deal.

Doug Free (DAL) – After parting ways with lifelong Cowboy, Flozell Adams, the Cowboys may have found their left tackle for the next decade in Doug Free. He isn’t quite the same run blocker, but he’s proven to be a significant upgrade in pass protection over what Adams has been the last several years. Free has 7 false starts this year, but has also only allowed 5 sacks. If he can clean up the mental problems, he should be a great blindside pass protector for many years in Dallas.

Jared Gaither (BAL) – Though rumors last offseason had Jared Gaither on the trade block, Gaither has proclaimed his desire to return to the Ravens next season. A back injury sidelined him for the entirety of this season and allowed Michael Oher to move into left tackle, where he’ll likely settle in. The injury may potentially allow the Ravens to pay Gaither as a right tackle, increasing the likelihood the organization brings him back.

Jammal Brown (WAS) – With rookie Trent Williams playing the left side, Jammal Brown has started on the right side for the first time since his rookie year. He struggled early in the season as he recovered from injury, but has since turned around his play. He’s a far cry from where he was in his prime, but the Redskins have had success running the ball behind him. The organization hasn’t shied away from spending money on players, but they could get a bargain in Brown, if he continues his upward ascension from injury.



Matt Light (NE) – Light will be 33 next season and coming off his worst season in several years giving up double digit sacks on the left side. 2nd year right tackle Sebastian Vollmer is coming off an All-Pro caliber season at right tackle and has proven capable of stonewalling pass rushers from the left side as well. The aging Matt Light finally seems expendable after giving Tom Brady nearly a decade of great protection.

Jermon Bushrod (NO) – Bushrod hasn’t been nearly as effective at left tackle this season as he was as a fill-in for Jammal Brown a season ago. He’s been average in both pass protection and run-blocking and has 6 false start penalties as well. With offensive guard Carl Nicks set to hit free agency as well, the Saints will likely worry more about their Pro Bowl caliber left guard before getting to Bushrod, especially if they believe Charles Brown is the eventual left tackle for the offense.

Willie Colon (PIT) – Colon had started 50 consecutive games for the Steelers at right tackle with improvement each year before missing all of 2010 with a torn Achilles. He was the team’s best blocker in 2009 and has surprisingly traveled with the organization for each of their games. With an offensive line that has been decimated by injury, the reunion of Colon and Pittsburgh in 2011 seems likely.

Other Notable Free Agents:
Alex Barron (DAL)
Ryan Harris (DEN)
Corey Hilliard (DET)
Rashad Butler (HOU)
Charlie Johnson (IND)
Ryan O'Callaghan (KC)
Pat McQuistan (MIA)
Ryan Cook (MIN)
Zach Strief (NO)
Wayne Hunter (NYJ)
Khalif Barnes (OAK)
Langston Walker (OAK)
Mario Henderson (OAK)
Trai Essex (PIT)
Jonathan Scott (PIT)
Jeromey Clary (SD)
Barry Sims (SF)
Sean Locklear (SEA)
Adam Goldberg (STL)
John Greco (STL)
Jeremy Trueblood (TB)
Stephon Heyer (WAS)


INTERIOR LINEMEN:

Carl Nicks (NO) – Both Jahri Evans and Nicks made it to the Pro Bowl this year, but it was Nicks who had the better season. The Saints run game was best when backs ran it up the middle and over left tackle, both partially attributed to Nicks’ success. The organization also just recently made Jahri Evans the league’s highest paid guard so it’ll be interesting to see if New Orleans also has the highest offer on the table for Nicks if he becomes an unrestricted free agent. They also have Bushrod and Jonathan Goodwin becoming free agents, so if they re-sign Nicks, it almost definitely will mean letting go of Bushrod at left tackle.

Logan Mankins (NE) – The return of Logan Mankins has reinstalled some more nasty into the offensive line and bolstered protection for Tom Brady who has been able to sit back in the pocket and not force throws. With his return, the Patriots have sustained success in the run game with Green-Ellis and Danny Woodhead, an unlikely tandem. Though he isn’t playing at quite the same level he was the past three seasons, Mankins continues to be one of the top guards in the league and will be handsomely rewarded this offseason.

Davin Joseph (TB) – Davin Joseph was playing terrific football for the Buccaneers before he fractured his foot in November, sending him to the IR. He’s an excellent run blocker and a good pass blocker, who will one of the top guards if the Buccaneers allow him to reach free agency. Don’t expect them to just let their best offensive linemen go without a fight though.

Harvey Dahl (ATL) – Ask opposing players who have faced Harvey Dahl and they’ll tell you that the right guard brings some extra nasty with him every week. He and Clabo combine to form a physical, dominant right side for the Atlanta Falcons, which allows the offense to control the line of scrimmage. Expect both to re-sign in Atlanta.

Ryan Kalil (CAR) – The Panthers have an uphill battle to return to the playoffs and seemingly have holes at nearly every position. However, center is not one of them, with Ryan Kalil playing consistently good football for them for the entirety of his rookie contract. Re-signing Kalil is the biggest no-brainer the Panthers have this year outside of drafting Andrew Luck if he decides to come out. Just don’t expect the team to use the franchise tag on him as offensive linemen are grouped together for the tag values, which means he’d be making the money of an offensive tackle.

Daryn Colledge (GB) – Colledge has been a bit up and down this season. The Packers have struggled to run the ball with any semblance of consistency and some of that can be attributed to the offensive line. Colledge isn’t able to move defenders off the ball with regularity, but is pretty good in pass protection. With TJ Lang and several other potential prospects vying for left guard, the Packers may not have the money to commit to Colledge after they negotiate with more pivotal free agents.

Other Notable Free Agents:
Alan Faneca (ARZ)
Deuce Lutui (ARZ)
Lyle Sendlein (ARZ)
Justin Blalock (ATL)
Chris Chester (BAL)
Marshal Yanda (BAL)
Olin Kreutz (CHI)
Evan Mathis (CIN)
Kyle Cook (CIN)
Nate Livings (CIN)
Kyle Kosier (DAL)
Jason Spitz (GB)
Kasey Studdard (HOU)
Mike Brisiel (HOU)
Kyle DeVan (IND)
Mike Pollak (IND)
Rudy Niswanger (KC)
Casey Wiegmann (KC)
Richie Incognito (MIA)
Nate Garner (MIA)
Jonathan Goodwin (NO)
Kevin Boothe (NYG)
Samson Satele (OAK)
Reggie Wells (PHI)
Scott Mruczkowski (SD)
David Baas (SF)
Chris Spencer (SEA)
Leroy Harris (TEN)
Will Montgomery (WAS)
 
Messages
46,859
Reaction score
5
Thanks for posting that, Po. There's a number of names on there I'd have an interest in.

I think we ought to focus on only fixing one side of the line this year -- the right side. Do that, squeeze one more year out of Kosier, and I think we'd see a marked improvement along our line play.

This isn't even taking into consideration improved coaching and more physical practices.
 

MichaelWinicki

In the Rotation
Messages
782
Reaction score
0
Thanks for posting that, Po. There's a number of names on there I'd have an interest in.

I think we ought to focus on only fixing one side of the line this year -- the right side. Do that, squeeze one more year out of Kosier, and I think we'd see a marked improvement along our line play.

This isn't even taking into consideration improved coaching and more physical practices.

I think two spots get changed for whenever football starts up again...

Colombo's for sure. No question.

The other? I'm not sure. Davis played better over the last half of the season so I'm not quite as sure he would be cut from the team. If not Davis, then I'd say Kosier's spot is up for grabs.

But would I be shocked if only one starter was replaced for the upcoming season– no.
 

NoShame

UDFA
Messages
2,797
Reaction score
0
Thanks for posting that, Po. There's a number of names on there I'd have an interest in.

I think we ought to focus on only fixing one side of the line this year -- the right side. Do that, squeeze one more year out of Kosier, and I think we'd see a marked improvement along our line play.

This isn't even taking into consideration improved coaching and more physical practices.

That would probably be the best way to go about it but being as Kosier is a FA... I think we're just gonna have to let him walk rather than re-signing him to a 1 yr contract.

We're gonna have to keep Davis, replace Columbo and find Kosier's replacement at guard. I'd love to see us replace everyone along the line save maybe Gurode but thats not very realistic.

Also, we MUST draft some depth for the line this year... we have to start producing our own starters rather than going out and buying them all the time.
 

MichaelWinicki

In the Rotation
Messages
782
Reaction score
0
This team is probably going to have to spend 2 draft picks on offensive lineman (and hope they "hit" with both of them) plus sign one starting capable FA.
 

sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
One thing to consider, and this is me at my absolute homer best, is that just by simply having a physical, demanding camp and continuing that into the practices during the season should help this offensive line.

We still need major upgrades everywhere, but I don't expect the same kind of play in 2011 even with minimal changes.
 

MichaelWinicki

In the Rotation
Messages
782
Reaction score
0
One thing to consider, and this is me at my absolute homer best, is that just by simply having a physical, demanding camp and continuing that into the practices during the season should help this offensive line.

We still need major upgrades everywhere, but I don't expect the same kind of play in 2011 even with minimal changes.

I agree with most of that.
 
Top Bottom