Cowboys fans want youth most, vet Newman least

[Cr122]

By ESPNDallas.com


With more than 200,000 votes in our take 'em or trash 'em feature, our readers consider two young players the most valuable members of the franchise.

Rookie running back DeMarco Murray and second-year linebacker Sean Lee are the only players to have a 99 percent approval rating from you.

The top keepers:
1. Murray 99%
1. Lee 99%
2. Jason Witten 98%
2. Laurent Robinson 98%
2. Tyron Smith 98 %
2. DeMarcus Ware 98%
2. Dan Bailey 98%

Other notable keepers: Tony Romo 91%, Dez Bryant 97%.

Top of the trash heap:
1. Terence Newman 97%
1. Chauncey Washington 97%
2. Frank Walker 94%
3. David Buehler 93%
4. Keith Brooking 92%
5. Jon Kitna 91%

You can still vote who to keep and trash here.

 

[Cr122]

I'd stick Bradie James, Anthony Spencer, and Alan Ball in the trash heap as well.

 

[Slatemosphere]

We have the pieces to be dominant. Jerry needs to go get Carl Nicks and draft Decastro. The defense will never be elite but look at the Saints and Pats D. Ya they have great QB's but they also have great Oline play. Not saying Romo is on their level but he's close if given time to throw.

 

[Cr122]

We have the pieces to be dominant. Jerry needs to go get Carl Nicks and draft Decastro. The defense will never be elite but look at the Saints and Pats D. Ya they have great QB's but they also have great Oline play. Not saying Romo is on their level but he's close if given time to throw.

I'd be on board with that. DeCastro's a beast, and Nick's a huge upgrade over Kosier or Holland.

 

[Slatemosphere]

I'd be on board with that. DeCastro's a beast, and Nick's a huge upgrade over Kosier or Holland.

It would also essentially solidify the O-line for 6-7 years.

LT-Smith (21 years old)
LG-Nicks (27 years old)
C-Kowalski (23 years old)
RG-Decastro(22 years old)
RT-Free(27 years old)

 

[RoyTheHammer]

It would also essentially solidify the O-line for 6-7 years.

LT-Smith (21 years old)
LG-Nicks (27 years old)
C-Kowalski (23 years old)
RG-Decastro(22 years old)
RT-Free(27 years old)

Just the thought of having that line is awesome. It has a pretty realistic shot of happening too.

 

[Cr122]

It would also essentially solidify the O-line for 6-7 years.

LT-Smith (21 years old)
LG-Nicks (27 years old)
C-Kowalski (23 years old)
RG-Decastro(22 years old)
RT-Free(27 years old)

If Sparano comes back that'll be a well coached group next year. They just got to keep Costa away from center.

 

[Cr122]

Just the thought of having that line is awesome. It has a pretty realistic shot of happening too.

That's where our brilliant GM's thinking cap must be put on.

Oh...wait.. forget it.

 

[UVAwahoos]

But wait. Casmith played DB in a powderpuff football game once, and thinks we should keep Newman. Clearly, our fans are confused.

 

[Cr122]

^^^^^^^^^^^^^

I found their team picture.....

 

[UVAwahoos]

lol

That must be a college photo.

Casmith was #74 in his earlier playing days.