Messages
5,432
Reaction score
0
Broncos give the keys to John Elway

Posted by Mike Florio on January 5, 2011, 10:01 AM EST

John Elway officially has returned to the Broncos. The team announced today that Elway will serve as Executive Vice President of Football Operations, a very big title for a guy whose only NFL experience consists of playing for an NFL team.

The team also announced that Chief Operating Officer Joe Ellis has been promoted to club president, a title that more accurately reflects the power and influence that Ellis has been wielding since coach Mike Shanahan was fired nearly two years ago.

“John Elway’s leadership, competitiveness and passion for the Denver Broncos will position this team for long-term success through his work leading our football operations,” owner Pat Bowlen said in a team-issued release. “John has won championships as both a player and executive, and his experience will be a valuable addition to this franchise. He is the perfect fit for this role, and I am excited to welcome him back to the Denver Broncos.”

His role will consist of directing the team’s football operations, overseeing the head coach and G.M. (for now) Brian Xanders.

Elway also will have final say over the personnel decisions, making him essentially the General Manager. He’ll also lead the search for a new coach.

Sorry, folks, but we remain very skeptical about this. Elway is getting the job without paying the dues. Watching film with his father and running an AFL franchise isn’t the kind of experience necessary to run an NFL team, and it’s sort of an insult to the men who have earned their stripes by grinding for years, learning the business from the bottom up and earning each next rung on the ladder.

It’s almost as if Bowlen and Ellis don’t know what else to do, so they’ll give the keys to a guy whose only real qualifications are his ability to throw a ball and the fact that his presence will sell tickets and/or restore hope, false as it may be.


A press conference will be held at 3:30 p.m. ET, at which time the likes of Woody Paige and the rest of the Denver media will likely pucker up for Elway, Ellis, and Bowlen. Here’s hoping that someone out there has the independence and the will to ask tough questions about the confusing decision to give so much responsibility and power to a guy who really has done nothing to merit it.

Also, don’t rule out the possibility that Elway will realize that working for a living is a lot more demanding than being a retired football star, as Dan Marino learned seven years ago, when he resigned as Senior Vice President of Football Operations in Miami after only three weeks on the job.

“I knew it would involve a significant lifestyle change, but after further reflection, it became clear that those adjustments were ones that my family and I are not prepared to make at this time,” Marino said at the time.

In other words, working for a living is a lot more demanding than being a retired football star.
 

sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
Sorry, folks, but we remain very skeptical about this. Elway is getting the job without paying the dues. Watching film with his father and running an AFL franchise isn’t the kind of experience necessary to run an NFL team, and it’s sort of an insult to the men who have earned their stripes by grinding for years, learning the business from the bottom up and earning each next rung on the ladder.

It’s almost as if Bowlen and Ellis don’t know what else to do, so they’ll give the keys to a guy whose only real qualifications are his ability to throw a ball and the fact that his presence will sell tickets and/or restore hope, false as it may be.

Cry me a river.

Talk to me when you have an owner who pretends he's a GM. And a bastard son waiting in the wings as the pretend VP of player personnel.
 
Messages
5,432
Reaction score
0
Matt Millen: I hope John Elway does better than I did

Posted by Michael David Smith on January 5, 2011, 8:45 AM EST

As a former player with no personnel experience getting the keys to an NFL franchise, John Elway is in exclusive company. There’s really only one recent example of the same thing happening, and that was Matt Millen’s tenure running the Detroit Lions.

Broncos fans, be afraid. Be very afraid.

Mike Klis of the Denver Post contacted Millen to ask about his experiences, and Millen acknowledged that the Broncos had better hope Elway is a whole lot better than he was.

“I hope John does better than I did, because I stunk at it,” Millen said.

Unlike Ozzie Newsome, a Hall of Fame player who worked his way up the personnel ladder before becoming G.M. of the Ravens, Elway and Millen got their jobs without having to learn the ropes first, although Elway does have a little more experience than Millen did, since Elway ran an Arena Football team. Millen said Elway may be surprised by what the job entails.

“There’s a misconception about the job,” Millen said. “It’s less about the game of football. It’s less about X’s and O’s. It’s less about personnel decisions. It’s a job about managing people. It’s about building a consensus when you pick the right head coach. You can’t go in and be this football czar and say this is how it’s going to work. If you pick somebody that a coach doesn’t like and doesn’t coach, that’s a bad situation.”

One difference between Elway and Millen is where they’re starting: Millen took over a Lions team that had gone 9-7 the previous season and promptly ran them into the ground. Elway is taking over a 4-12 Broncos team that has nowhere to go but up.

And Millen does believe Elway can turn the Broncos around.

“Absolutely,” Millen said. “John has a shot to be successful.”
 
C

Cr122

Guest
I think Elway will do a good job.

He was a winner, and he knows football, it's not like he was selling oil before he came here.
 
Messages
5,432
Reaction score
0
Cry me a river.

Talk to me when you have an owner who pretends he's a GM. And a bastard son waiting in the wings as the pretend VP of player personnel.

There are plenty of other threads on this board which you can voice your displeasure with Jerry and son.

This is a thread about the Broncos and Elway, please don't hijack it.
 
Messages
46,859
Reaction score
5
I think Elway will do a good job.

He was a winner, and he knows football, it's not like he was selling oil before he came here.

He won't.

This is a stupid move, for marketing purposes only.
 

sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
He has no prior background, so he doesn't deserve the job. But it is possible that by random dumb luck he has a gift for it.
 

LAZARUS_LOGAN

Pro Bowler
Messages
14,639
Reaction score
207
I think Elway will do a good job.

He was a winner, and he knows football, it's not like he was selling oil before he came here.


Well Jerry can make the same claim. He also was a winner and knows football. He was the starting guard on the National Champion Razorbacks.
 

Cythim

2
Messages
3,919
Reaction score
0
Well Jerry can make the same claim. He also was a winner and knows football. He was the starting guard on the National Champion Razorbacks.

Huge difference between starting guard for a college NC team and starting QB for a team winning back to back Super Bowls.
 

LAZARUS_LOGAN

Pro Bowler
Messages
14,639
Reaction score
207
Huge difference between starting guard for a college NC team and starting QB for a team winning back to back Super Bowls.


My point is that neither one really qualifies the other for the position that they hold. So no it is not a huge difference. Throwing a football and guiding a team as a player on the field does not automatically transfers into success in the position Elway now holds.
 
Messages
46,859
Reaction score
5
I agree.

Just because you were a great QB doesn't mean you can run a front office.

Ridiculous hire.

I'm an Elway fan, so I hope he has some success.
 

sbk92

2
Messages
12,134
Reaction score
6
He clearly doesn't deserve the gig, but that doesn't mean he's going to definitely fail.

It could be a random dumb luck thing. Like when Jerry brought in his college roommate to Dallas.
 
Top Bottom